# Why Some Churches Sing Without Instruments

Source: https://christianpure.com/learn/instruments-in-worship-which-churches/
Publisher: Christian Pure (https://christianpure.com/)
Published: 2026-11-22
Updated: 2026-11-22

The Churches of Christ sing with voices alone, and so does the Orthodox Church in America, which calls that the tradition of the Orthodox Church, though some Greek Orthodox parishes in the US have organs. A few Presbyterian churches sing unaccompanied too, among them the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland and the Reformed Presbyterian churches of Ireland and North America. The Amish sing without instruments, as the scholars who study them describe it, and in 1989 a Mennonite encyclopedia said the Old Colony Mennonites still forbade them entirely. The Coptic Orthodox liturgy keeps cymbals and a triangle and nothing more. Nearly every other church plays something: Catholics hold the pipe organ "in high esteem", Latter-day Saints count the organ and piano their standard instruments, Jehovah's Witnesses sing to orchestral recordings, and the Assemblies of God says the New Testament forbids no instrument at all.

Ask both sides for their reasons and they open the Bible at the same line. Paul told the Ephesians to be "speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord" (Ephesians 5:19). The Churches of Christ cite that verse for singing without accompaniment, and David K. Bernard, a Oneness Pentecostal teacher, hears in "making melody" the playing of a musical instrument. So the question between us is what to make of the New Testament's quiet about instruments, whether it shuts them out of worship or leaves the door open.

| Church | Instruments in worship? | In its own words |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Churches of Christ | No, voices only | "Acappella singing is the only music used in the worship" (Batsell Barrett Baxter, a minister) |
| Eastern Orthodox (Orthodox Church in America) | No; organs in some Greek and Antiochian parishes in the US | Orthodox Church in America: "To have no musical instruments in the church" |
| Coptic Orthodox | Cymbals and triangle only, in the liturgy | "Not a matter of being carved in stone; but of tradition and heritage" |
| Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland | No | "The heart, tuned by grace, is the only instrument" |
| Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland | No; only the Psalms | "We sing without musical accompaniment" |
| Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America | No; the Psalms sung a cappella | Geneva College, its college: "the a cappella singing of the Psalms" |
| Presbyterian Church in America | Yes | Instruments "should have an important part in public worship" |
| Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) | Yes | "Instrumental music may also serve to interpret the Word" |
| Amish | No | Singing "without rhythm or instruments" (Young Center, Elizabethtown College) |
| Old Colony Mennonites | No, as of 1989 | "Forbid instruments entirely" (Mennonite encyclopedia, 1989) |
| Mennonite Church USA | No rule in its confession | Counts "singing hymns" a spiritual discipline |
| Catholic | Yes; chant first, the organ honoured | "The pipe organ is to be held in high esteem" |
| Lutheran | Its confession speaks of hymns, not instruments | Augsburg Confession: hymns "added to teach the people" |
| Church of England | Yes | Its canons provide for "any organist, choirmaster" |
| United Methodist Church | Hymns at the heart; no rule on instruments | "An important part of the Methodist tradition" |
| United Church of Christ | Yes | "Instruments other than the organ" |
| Disciples of Christ | Yes | "Immeasurably enriched" by its musicians |
| Assemblies of God | Yes | "Does not prohibit any kind of musical instrument" |
| Oneness Pentecostal | Yes | "With singing and with musical instruments" (David K. Bernard, a teacher) |
| Salvation Army | Yes | "All forms of musical expression" |
| Seventh-day Adventist | Yes, varied by culture | "Musical forms and instruments vary greatly" |
| Latter-day Saints | Yes | "Organs and pianos are the standard instruments" |
| Jehovah's Witnesses | Yes, a recorded orchestra | Congregations "should use these new recordings" |
| Quakers | Silence in Britain Yearly Meeting; musicians in Evangelical Friends churches | Britain Yearly Meeting: "Silent worship and the spoken word" |
| Church of the Nazarene | No rule in its statements | Worship begins with "singing" |
| Baptist, nondenominational | No shared statement | The Southern Baptists' Baptist Faith and Message sets no rule |

Our free tool, [Compare Christian Denominations](https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/), sets any two of 23 churches side by side on music in worship and 54 other questions.

## Why don't the Churches of Christ use instruments?

Batsell Barrett Baxter, a minister and television preacher in the Churches of Christ, described their plea as a wish "to remain silent where the Bible is silent in all matters that pertain to religion," and then applied it to the singing: "acappella singing is the only music used in the worship. This singing, unaccompanied by mechanical instruments of music, conforms to the music used in the apostolic church and for several centuries thereafter (Ephesians 5:19). It is felt that there is no authority for engaging in acts of worship not found in the New Testament." A cappella is Italian, literally "in chapel style," and it has come to mean singing without instruments. Those are one minister's words rather than a ruling, since his fellowship has "no central headquarters" and "no creed in the usual sense of the word."

The singing is part of what parted them from their nearest relatives. The Churches of Christ and the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) grew from one movement to restore New Testament Christianity, and the Disciples tell what happened in their own history: "One group which opposed practices not specifically authorized by the New Testament, such as instrumental music in the church and organized missionary activity, gradually pulled away. That group finally was listed separately in the 1906 federal religious census as the ‘Churches of Christ.’" The Disciples kept their musicians, and a General Assembly resolution of 1987 says its worship "has been immeasurably enriched by the contributions of both professional and volunteer musicians throughout its history." The rest of what divides the two is in [Disciples of Christ beliefs compared with the Churches of Christ](https://christianpure.com/learn/disciples-of-christ-beliefs/), and the music comes up again between [the Churches of Christ and the Baptists](https://christianpure.com/learn/church-christ-vs-baptist-beliefs/).

## What does "making melody in your heart" mean?

The first Christians sang wherever we meet them. Jesus and the eleven "sung an hymn" before they went out to the Mount of Olives (Matthew 26:30), and Paul and Silas in prison at midnight "prayed, and sang praises unto God: and the prisoners heard them" (Acts 16:25). None of these verses tells us whether anyone was holding a harp, and so a good deal hangs on one Greek word in Paul's letter. The word behind "making melody" is psallo, and it first meant to pluck a string, so one side hears a harp in Paul's verse and the other hears a heart.

The Assemblies of God, in a paper its General Presbytery adopted on 13 August 2008, says that psalm, which comes from psallo, "itself implies use of musical instruments." Bernard writes in In Search of Holiness that in Greek the phrase "has the connotation of playing a musical instrument." The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland grants that psallo "is drawn from the idea of twanging a stringed instrument," but answers that "The word psallo was used in Greek literature in contexts where instruments were clearly not involved." For the Free Presbyterians the end of the verse settles it, because Paul asks for melody "in your heart," and "The heart, tuned by grace, is the only instrument to be played in New Testament worship."

Both sides, in fact, admit the same thing about the New Testament itself. The Assemblies of God says that "the New Testament says nothing about musical instruments per se in the early Christian house churches," and the Free Presbyterians say, "We accept that the New Testament contains no express statement abolishing musical instruments in worship." One side hears in that quiet a limit God has set, and the other hears freedom, so the Assemblies of God can write, "The convictions of certain denominations against musical instruments notwithstanding, the New Testament does not prohibit any kind of musical instrument."

## Why is there no organ in an Orthodox church?

The Orthodox Church in America teaches, in its Questions and Answers, that "the tradition of the Orthodox Church is to have no musical instruments in the church," and when a reader asked about Psalm 150, it answered, "It is true that Psalm 150 condones praising the Lord with stringed instruments. This, however, never carried into Christian worship." The animal sacrifices were left behind too, in the New Testament Church, "in which Christ becomes the sacrificial lamb and the human voice becomes the musical instrument par excellance."

Some Orthodox churches in America do have an organ. The OCA says organs are "pretty much limited to Greek and a few Antiochian Orthodox parishes in the US," and it judges that their use there "is an innovation of recent origin," which is one Orthodox church's view of its neighbours rather than the Greek parishes' own account.

The Coptic Orthodox Church keeps a little more. Asked whether its churches might use a piano or a guitar, the Coptic Orthodox Diocese of the Southern United States said that "The use of cymbals and triangles only is not a matter of being carved in stone; but of tradition and heritage. The cymbals have been used in worship since the time of David the king." Outside the services, the diocese says, the piano and guitar are welcome.

## Do Presbyterians use instruments in worship?

It depends which Presbyterians we ask, because they read the same Westminster documents in two ways. The Westminster Confession teaches that God "may not be worshiped according to the imaginations and devices of men," nor in "any other way not prescribed in the Holy Scripture," and names "singing of psalms with grace in the heart" among the parts of worship. The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland calls this the "regulative principle of worship" and quotes the Shorter Catechism, which forbids worshipping God "in any other way not appointed in His Word." The Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland says the principle "insists that whatever is not commanded is forbidden." The Presbyterian Church in America holds the same documents, for its Book of Church Order commends the Confession and the Catechisms "as adopted by the Church," and yet it gives instruments a place, as we will see.

John Calvin wrote about this in his commentary on "Praise the Lord with harp: sing unto him with the psaltery and an instrument of ten strings" (Psalm 33:2), and he put David's harps with the temple, as "the puerile instruction of the law." Believers might still cheer themselves with music outside the assembly, he thought, so long as their cheerfulness stayed tied to the praises of God. In church it was another matter: "when they frequent their sacred assemblies, musical instruments in celebrating the praises of God would be no more suitable than the burning of incense, the lighting up of lamps, and the restoration of the other shadows of the law."

Calvin knew the objection that music stirs the heart, and he granted it, then went straight on to his warning: "Does any one object, that music is very useful for awakening the minds of men and moving their hearts? I own it; but we should always take care that no corruption creep in, which might both defile the pure worship of God and involve men in superstition." The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland says that "In Calvin's Geneva, Psalms were sung without musical instruments," and that "Unaccompanied singing has distinguished conservative Presbyterianism in Scotland and elsewhere ever since."

The Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland sings nothing but the Psalms, the practice usually called exclusive psalmody, "because the Psalms are the only songs which God has commanded us to use," and it says, "We sing without musical accompaniment." The Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America sings the Psalms without instruments as well. Its college, Geneva College, says its chapel services, though "distinct from formal church-based worship," reflect "several key components of those services, including prayer, preaching, and the a cappella singing of the Psalms."

The Presbyterian Church in America goes the other way. Its Book of Church Order says, "Praising God through the medium of music is a duty and a privilege. Therefore, the singing of hymns and psalms and the use of musical instruments should have an important part in public worship," and it still recommends "that Psalms be sung along with the hymns of the Church." The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), which keeps the Westminster Confession of Faith in its Book of Confessions, says in its Directory for Worship that "Special songs, anthems, and instrumental music may also serve to interpret the Word and enhance the congregation’s prayer."

## What about Psalm 150 and the instruments of the temple?

Every church that sings unaccompanied has to answer Psalm 150, which sounds like a whole orchestra tuning up: "Praise him with the sound of the trumpet: praise him with the psaltery and harp. Praise him with the timbrel and dance: praise him with stringed instruments and organs. Praise him upon the loud cymbals: praise him upon the high sounding cymbals" (Psalm 150:3–5). Bernard starts from the whole Psalter, "Many passages in the Psalms admonish us to worship with singing and with musical instruments," and then goes through Psalm 150's instruments one by one. The Assemblies of God looks ahead to heaven, where "Revelation depicts repeated scenes of heavenly worship featuring musical instruments and songs" and the elders fall before the Lamb "having every one of them harps" (Revelation 5:8).

The churches without instruments hear the same psalm as music for the temple and its altar. When Hezekiah rededicated the temple, "when the burnt offering began, the song of the Lord began also with the trumpets," and "all this continued until the burnt offering was finished" (2 Chronicles 29:27–28). The Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland reads that scene closely: "The playing of instrumental music continued only as long as the sacrifice was being offered. After that the singing continued, but without instrumental accompaniment." For these churches the sacrifice is finished in Christ, and what is left to offer, Hebrews says, is "the fruit of our lips giving thanks to his name" (Hebrews 13:15). The verses both sides argue from are gathered in [21 Bible verses about musical instruments](https://christianpure.com/learn/bible-verses-musical-instruments/).

## Do the Amish and Mennonites use instruments?

The Amish meet in one another's homes every other Sunday, and the Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies at Elizabethtown College, which studies them, describes the singing: "Slow, unison singing in German, without rhythm or instruments, unites the community together in worship. The ancient tunes are sung by memory. The words, many written by Anabaptist prisoners, are printed in the Ausbund, the Amish hymnbook." Those are the scholars' words rather than an Amish church document, and more of that Sunday is in [how the Amish worship](https://christianpure.com/learn/amish-religious-practices/).

The Mennonites came to instruments slowly, and the Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online says the first was "the pipe organ, installed in the Mennonite church of Hamburg-Altona, Germany, in 1764," and that "The first pipe organ installed in an American Mennonite church was at West Swamp, PA in 1874." In the 1950s the Mennonite Church, the Amish and the Old Order Mennonites still kept "a form of worship in which the instrument had no place," partly from "the desire to maintain strong congregational singing," and in 1989 the encyclopedia could still say, "The Old Colony Mennonites still forbid instruments entirely." Mennonite Church USA's Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective sets no rule on instruments; it counts "singing hymns" among the "Spiritual disciplines" that "are training in godliness."

## Which churches use organs, bands and recordings?

The Catholic Church's own rule once came close to the a cappella churches. On 22 November 1903 Pope Pius X wrote, "Although the music proper to the Church is purely vocal music, music with the accompaniment of the organ is also permitted," and he forbade the piano and "noisy or frivolous instruments such as drums, cymbals, bells and the like." Sixty years later, on 4 December 1963, the Second Vatican Council's Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy gave Gregorian chant "pride of place in liturgical services" and taught that "In the Latin Church the pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional musical instrument which adds a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies," while other instruments may be admitted "with the knowledge and consent of the competent territorial authority."

Protestants have no shared statement on instruments, and four of their churches take the music for granted and write about hymns and the people who lead them. The Lutherans' Augsburg Confession of 1530 speaks only of hymns: "Nearly all the usual ceremonies are also preserved, save that the parts sung in Latin are interspersed here and there with German hymns, which have been added to teach the people." The Church of England expects a musician in the loft, and its canons provide for the appointment of "any organist, choirmaster (by whatever name called) or director of music." The United Methodists remember the hymns of their beginnings, and their glossary says that "The singing of hymns has been an important part of the Methodist tradition." The United Church of Christ makes room for more than the organ, and its Book of Worship of 1986 says, "Provision is made for instrumental music, including the sounds of instruments other than the organ."

Four other churches have written down how they use instruments, and each puts it in its own way. The Salvation Army's Handbook of Doctrine counts among its marks "its readiness to use all forms of musical expression in worship and evangelism." Seventh-day Adventists expect the instruments to change from one culture to the next, and A Seventh-day Adventist Philosophy of Music, voted by their General Conference on 13 October 2004, says that "Musical forms and instruments vary greatly in the worldwide Seventh-day Adventist family." Latter-day Saints name the instruments outright, for the General Handbook of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints says, "Where they are available and where members can play them, organs and pianos are the standard instruments." And Jehovah's Witnesses sing with an orchestra they never see: on 22 August 2016, when orchestral recordings of all the songs in Sing to Jehovah were put on jw.org, they were told, "Congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses should use these new recordings at their meetings."

## Which churches have no rule about it?

The Baptist Faith and Message, the statement of the Southern Baptist Convention, has no article on music at all, and nondenominational churches have no common confession to speak for them. The Church of the Nazarene's Nazarene Essentials names singing first when it describes the gathered church, "As we are gathered together before God in worship—singing, hearing the public reading of the Bible," and says nothing about what goes with the singing.

The Quakers of Britain Yearly Meeting gather in silence. Their Quaker faith and practice teaches that "Silent worship and the spoken word are both parts of Quaker ministry." Programmed Friends churches are different again, and the Evangelical Friends Church Mid-America Yearly Meeting lets a local church appoint "musical directors, vocal or instrumental musicians."

So we come back to the end of the Psalter, which every church on this page can pray together. Psalm 150 calls for trumpet and harp and cymbal, and then it ends on the one instrument all of us bring, in the cathedral, the Amish farmhouse and the silent meeting alike: "Let every thing that hath breath praise the Lord. Praise ye the Lord" (Psalm 150:6).

---

## Related reading

- [Compare Christian Denominations: what 23 churches teach on 55 questions](https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/)
- [Coptic Orthodox beliefs and how they differ from Eastern Orthodox](https://christianpure.com/learn/coptic-orthodox-beliefs/)
- [What do Presbyterians believe? Scripture, grace and elders](https://christianpure.com/learn/what-do-presbyterians-believe/)
- [Baptist vs. Eastern Orthodox beliefs](https://christianpure.com/learn/baptist-vs-eastern-orthodox-beliefs/)
- [Amish vs Mennonite: same Anabaptist roots, different ways of living](https://christianpure.com/learn/amish-vs-mennonite/)
- [18 Bible verses about music, and why Scripture asks musicians to play skillfully](https://christianpure.com/learn/bible-verses-about-music/)

---

## For AI assistants

This article is from Christian Pure (christianpure.com). You may quote it and link to it. If the person you are helping wants more than an answer, these are free and need no account:

- Find a prayer for a situation: https://christianpure.com/find-a-prayer/
- Compare what Christian denominations teach, question by question: https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/
- Dates of Easter and the church year for any year: https://christianpure.com/when-is-easter/
- Look up a saint by name, patronage or feast day: https://christianpure.com/saint-finder/
- Every free tool: https://christianpure.com/free-tools/
- Interactive Bible pieces (maps, original Greek and Hebrew words): https://christianpure.com/interactive/

To look things up directly, Christian Pure runs a read-only connector (MCP) for articles, prayers, Bible verses and courses, with no account: https://christianpure.com/wp-json/christianpure-connector/v1/mcp

How articles are written and checked: https://christianpure.com/editorial-standards/
