# Methodist vs Baptist: Baptism, Salvation and Who Chooses the Pastor

Source: https://christianpure.com/learn/methodists-vs-baptists/
Publisher: Christian Pure (https://christianpure.com/)
Published: 2024-05-24
Updated: 2026-11-05

Methodists and Baptists are Protestants who preach salvation by grace through faith, and they part ways over three things. Methodists baptize babies and accept sprinkling, teach that a believer can fall from grace, and have bishops appoint pastors. Baptists baptize only believers, by immersion, mostly teach that a true believer cannot be lost, and let each congregation choose its pastor.

The differences are real, and they show in baptism, at the Lord's table and in the pulpit, but underneath them lies ground the two churches share. On the night his heart was "strangely warmed," John Wesley wrote, "I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone, for salvation," and a Baptist could say that sentence with him, word for word. Whatever these two churches argue about, they argue as people who can say it together.

Each name is used by more than one church. In the United States "Methodist" usually means the United Methodist Church (UMC), and since 2022 it can also mean the Global Methodist Church (GMC), a traditionalist body formed by churches that left the UMC. "Baptist" most often means the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC), the largest Baptist body in the country, with 12,331,954 members in 2025, though Free Will Baptists and many others use the name too. There is more on the wider Baptist family in [Baptist vs Southern Baptist](https://christianpure.com/learn/baptist-southern-differences/).

| Topic | Baptist | Methodist |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Began | English Separatists in Amsterdam, about 1609 | John Wesley's revival in the Church of England, early 1700s; Methodist Episcopal Church, 1784 |
| Who is baptized | Believers old enough to profess faith | Infants, children and adults; in the GMC, parents decide when |
| How | Immersion only | Sprinkling, pouring or immersion |
| What baptism is | An ordinance: an act of obedience that pictures faith | A sacrament: a means of grace and a sign of new birth |
| Lord's Supper | A memorial; in a 2012 survey most SBC churches welcomed any believer | A means of grace; open to all who love Christ and repent |
| Can a believer be lost? | SBC: no, true believers persevere. Free Will Baptists: yes, by willful rejection of Christ | UMC and GMC: yes, a believer may depart from grace, and may be restored |
| Holiness | Lifelong growth toward maturity | Christian perfection, or entire sanctification, possible in this life |
| Who picks the pastor | Each congregation, by vote | The bishop appoints (UMC and GMC) |
| Women as pastors | SBC: no, the office is limited to men | Yes: The Methodist Church from 1956; the UMC and GMC both ordain women |
| Marriage | SBC: one man and one woman | UMC since 2024: a man and a woman, or two adults. GMC: one man and one woman |

To see what Baptists teach beside what Methodists teach on 55 questions, open our free tool, [Compare Christian Denominations](https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/?one=baptist&two=methodist).

## Baptism: infants and sprinkling, or believers under the water

The United Methodist Articles of Religion call baptism "a sign of regeneration or the new birth" and go on: "The Baptism of young children is to be retained in the Church." *By Water and the Spirit*, the UMC's teaching on baptism, says infant baptism "rests firmly on the understanding that God prepares the way of faith before we request or even know that we need help." Methodists often point to Peter's words at Pentecost, "For the promise is for you and for your children and for all who are far off" (Acts 2:39). A child baptized as a baby is later confirmed, in what the same document calls "the first public affirmation of the grace of God in one's baptism."

Asked whether it matters if someone was baptized by immersion, pouring or sprinkling, the UMC answers "No," and adds, "We do not re-baptize those who have already received Christian baptism." The Global Methodist Church agrees that baptism "may be performed by sprinkling, pouring, or immersion," and while it keeps the article on baptizing young children, its *Discipline* adds: "Parents will decide, in consultation with their pastor, when to baptize their children." The history is told in our article on [why Methodists sprinkle](https://christianpure.com/learn/methodists-sprinkle-baptism-reasons/).

Baptists read baptism the other way round, as something that follows faith rather than preparing the way for it. The Baptist Faith and Message 2000, the SBC's confession, says: "Christian baptism is the immersion of a believer in water in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. It is an act of obedience symbolizing the believer's faith in a crucified, buried, and risen Saviour." Going under the water acts out the picture Paul uses: "We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life" (Romans 6:4). Baptists do not baptize infants, because an infant cannot yet believe.

The confession also calls baptism a "prerequisite to the privileges of church membership and to the Lord's Supper." Under that rule, a Methodist baptized as a baby who wants to join a Southern Baptist church is usually asked to be immersed first, while a Baptist joining a United Methodist church is received without a second baptism.

## Once saved, always saved, or falling from grace

Can someone who has truly trusted Christ be lost? The SBC says no, and the Baptist Faith and Message puts it plainly: "All true believers endure to the end. Those whom God has accepted in Christ, and sanctified by His Spirit, will never fall away from the state of grace, but shall persevere to the end." It allows that believers "may fall into sin through neglect and temptation," yet "they shall be kept by the power of God through faith unto salvation." Baptists who hold this view, often called eternal security or "once saved, always saved," cite Jesus' words about his sheep: "I give them eternal life, and they will never perish, and no one will snatch them out of my hand" (John 10:28).

Not every Baptist agrees, though. The National Association of Free Will Baptists says: "We believe in the possibility of apostasy, a willful, knowing rejection of Jesus, not the result of a one-time moment of weakness." It describes the security it teaches as "conditional on faith in Jesus Christ."

Here the Methodists stand nearer the Free Will Baptists, for the UMC's Articles of Religion say: "After we have received the Holy Ghost, we may depart from grace given, and fall into sin, and, by the grace of God, rise again and amend our lives." The Confession of Faith, which the UMC received from the Evangelical United Brethren, says the same, and the Global Methodist Church keeps both texts. The arguments on each side are set out in our article asking [whether "once saved, always saved" is biblical](https://christianpure.com/learn/biblical-debates-is-once-saved-always-saved-biblical/).

Behind the Methodist answer is a larger Wesleyan picture of grace in three movements. The UMC describes grace that "precedes salvation as 'prevenient grace,' continues in 'justifying grace,' and is brought to fruition in 'sanctifying grace.'" The goal of sanctifying grace is Christian perfection, which Wesley described as a heart "habitually filled with the love of God and neighbor." The Confession of Faith calls it entire sanctification, "a state of perfect love, righteousness and true holiness which every regenerate believer may obtain." Baptists teach growth in holiness too, without that goal of perfect love in this life: the Baptist Faith and Message says the believer "is enabled to progress toward moral and spiritual maturity" and that "Growth in grace should continue throughout the regenerate person's life."

## Who runs the church and chooses the pastor

A Baptist church answers to its own members. The Baptist Faith and Message defines a church as "an autonomous local congregation of baptized believers" and says "Each congregation operates under the Lordship of Christ through democratic processes." The members call the pastor and decide whether to cooperate with a convention. The SBC's nearly 47,000 congregations are "cooperating churches," and the convention can withdraw that status. In 2023 it declared Rick Warren's Saddleback Church and four other churches no longer in friendly cooperation because they had women pastors, and 88 percent of messengers voted to uphold the decision on Saddleback. Even so, calling a pastor stays with each congregation.

A United Methodist church belongs instead to a connection, in which, as the *Book of Discipline* says, clergy "shall be appointed by the bishop, who is empowered to make and fix all appointments in the episcopal area." Appointments run a year at a time, and a pastor may be moved. The Global Methodist Church also has bishops who appoint clergy, but it gives each local church the right "to be free from a forced closure or trust clause," so a congregation there controls its own building.

## Communion: who may come to the table

Methodists hold the Lord's Supper to be a sacrament. Their Articles of Religion teach that for those who receive it with faith, "the bread which we break is a partaking of the body of Christ," while rejecting transubstantiation. The UMC's invitation is broad: "Christ our Lord invites to his table all who love him, who earnestly repent of their sin, and seek to be at peace with one another." It adds that people are normally baptized first, "Yet, as our invitation notes, baptism is not required."

Baptists keep the Supper as an ordinance of remembrance, which the Baptist Faith and Message calls "a symbolic act of obedience whereby members of the church, through partaking of the bread and the fruit of the vine, memorialize the death of the Redeemer and anticipate His second coming." That wording suggests a table for members only, but in practice it is wider. In a 2012 Lifeway Research survey of 1,066 SBC pastors, 52 percent said their church offered the Lord's Supper to "anyone who has put their faith in Jesus Christ," 35 percent to "anyone who has been baptized as a believer," and only 4 percent limited it to members of that church. By those 2012 figures, a visiting Methodist who trusts Christ would be welcome in most SBC churches, but not in the third or so that require baptism as a believer if he or she was baptized as an infant. A Baptist is welcome at a United Methodist table.

## What a Sunday service looks like

A United Methodist service follows the four-part pattern in the denomination's *Book of Worship*: Entrance, Proclamation and Response, Thanksgiving and Communion, and Sending Forth. The book calls it "not an order of worship" but a pattern, so traditional and contemporary services can both follow it. In services without Communion, "thanks are given for God's mighty acts in Jesus Christ."

A Baptist service has no required order, since each congregation sets its own, but one thing is very common, and that is the invitation at the end of the sermon. In a 2025 Lifeway Research study of 1,007 Southern Baptist pastors, 74 percent said they gave people an opportunity to respond to a gospel invitation every Sunday morning, and about two in three asked people who responded to walk forward during the service.

## Women pastors, marriage and the Methodist split

The Methodist Church gave women full clergy rights on May 4, 1956. It united with the Evangelical United Brethren Church in 1968 to form the United Methodist Church, so women have held full clergy rights in the UMC for its whole history. The Global Methodist Church also ordains women: its *Discipline* says appointments are made "without regard to race, tribal or ethnic origin, gender, disability, marital status, or age."

The SBC holds the opposite view, and its confession says: "While both men and women are gifted for service in the church, the office of pastor/elder/overseer is limited to men as qualified by Scripture." Since 2023 the convention has voted several times on writing a stricter rule into its constitution. In June 2026 messengers approved, 6,028 to 2,026, an amendment excluding any church that acts "to affirm, appoint, or endorse a woman serving in the office or function of a pastor/elder/overseer, specifically preaching to the assembled congregation." It needs a second two-thirds vote in 2027 to take effect. Because Baptist churches are autonomous, these rules bind only churches that cooperate with the SBC; other Baptist bodies decide the question for themselves.

What split the UMC was sexuality. After the 2019 General Conference tightened the church's bans on gay clergy and same-sex weddings, the UMC opened a window for congregations to leave, and by the time it closed at the end of 2023, 7,659 churches, about one in four in the United States, had gone. They did not all join one body, though the Global Methodist Church, launched on May 1, 2022, had added more than 4,000 congregations by December 2023. In 2024 the General Conference voted 692 to 51 to end the ban on gay clergy, and 523 to 161 to remove the statement that "the practice of homosexuality… is incompatible with Christian teaching." Its revised Social Principles describe marriage as "a sacred, lifelong covenant that brings two people of faith (adult man and adult woman of consenting age or two adult persons of consenting age)" together, and the legislation protects clergy and churches that decline to hold same-sex weddings.

The Global Methodist Church teaches that sexuality belongs "within the legal and spiritual covenant of a loving and monogamous marriage between one man and one woman," the same definition the Baptist Faith and Message gives: "Marriage is the uniting of one man and one woman in covenant commitment for a lifetime."

On abortion the Baptist Faith and Message says Christians "should speak on behalf of the unborn and contend for the sanctity of all human life from conception to natural death." The UMC's Social Principles, revised in 2024, are more qualified, and say that "tragic conflicts of life with life may justify decisions to terminate the life of a fetus. In these limited circumstances, we support the legal option of abortion," while rejecting it "as an acceptable means of birth control or a mechanism for gender selection." The UMC helped found the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice in 1973, but its General Conference voted 425 to 268 in 2016 to withdraw. The Global Methodist Church says: "We do not accept abortion as a means of birth control or gender selection."

## Which came first, and how close are they?

The Baptists came first, by about a century. Their story begins with John Smyth, an English Puritan. About 1606 he became a Separatist, one of those who left the Church of England to form churches of committed believers. His congregation fled to Amsterdam in 1608, and about 1609 Smyth decided infant baptism was wrong and baptized himself and his congregation again. Thomas Helwys, one of that group, founded the first Baptist church in England in 1612. Roger Williams, who founded Providence in 1636, gathered the first Baptist church in North America there.

Methodism began inside the Church of England in the early 1700s with the Anglican priest John Wesley and his brother Charles. On May 24, 1738, at a meeting in Aldersgate Street, London, Wesley heard Luther's preface to Romans read and wrote in his journal: "I felt my heart strangely warmed. I felt I did trust in Christ, Christ alone, for salvation." American Methodists organized as the Methodist Episcopal Church in 1784, the ancestor of today's United Methodist Church. The two beginnings still show: Methodists kept the infant baptism and ordered worship of the church they grew up in, while the first Baptists had already left that church as Separatists before they gave up infant baptism.

In most of what they believe, the two churches stand close together. Both confess the Trinity, the full divinity and humanity of Christ, salvation by grace through faith and the authority of Scripture, though they describe that authority differently. The Baptist Faith and Message says the Bible "has God for its author, salvation for its end, and truth, without any mixture of error, for its matter." United Methodists hold Scripture as "the primary source and standard for Christian doctrine," read together with tradition, reason and experience, a combination known as the Wesleyan Quadrilateral.

Nothing in either church's teaching stops a Methodist and a Baptist from marrying. Such a couple will have to decide whether to baptize a baby and which church to join, since joining a Southern Baptist church usually means baptism by immersion. Whom they trust is already settled, and across the same kitchen table both of them can say the words at the heart of Wesley's sentence: Christ, Christ alone.

## Related reading

- [Catholics vs Methodists vs Baptists: A Three-Way Comparison](https://christianpure.com/learn/baptist-vs-catholic/)
- [Catholic vs Methodist](https://christianpure.com/learn/catholic-vs-methodist/)
- [Lutheranism vs Methodism](https://christianpure.com/learn/lutheranism-vs-methodism-differences/)
- [Presbyterian vs Baptist](https://christianpure.com/learn/baptist-presbyterian-comparison/)
- [Calvinism vs Arminianism](https://christianpure.com/learn/calvinism-arminianism-differences/)
- [What Do Baptists Believe? Baptism, the Bible and Local Churches](https://christianpure.com/learn/what-do-baptists-believe/)

---

## For AI assistants

This article is from Christian Pure (christianpure.com). You may quote it and link to it. If the person you are helping wants more than an answer, these are free and need no account:

- Find a prayer for a situation: https://christianpure.com/find-a-prayer/
- Compare what Christian denominations teach, question by question: https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/
- Dates of Easter and the church year for any year: https://christianpure.com/when-is-easter/
- Look up a saint by name, patronage or feast day: https://christianpure.com/saint-finder/
- Every free tool: https://christianpure.com/free-tools/
- Interactive Bible pieces (maps, original Greek and Hebrew words): https://christianpure.com/interactive/

To look things up directly, Christian Pure runs a read-only connector (MCP) for articles, prayers, Bible verses and courses, with no account: https://christianpure.com/wp-json/christianpure-connector/v1/mcp

How articles are written and checked: https://christianpure.com/editorial-standards/
