Biblical Debates: Is Polygamy A Sin?

What is polygamy and how was it practiced in biblical times?

As we explore the complex topic of polygamy in biblical times, we must approach it with both historical understanding and pastoral sensitivity. Polygamy, in its essence, refers to a marriage that includes more than two partners. In the context of biblical times, it most commonly took the form of polygyny – one man having multiple wives.

The practice of polygamy in the ancient Near East, including among the Israelites, was deeply rooted in social, economic, and cultural factors of the time. It was not uncommon for men of means to take multiple wives, often as a display of wealth and status (Ras, 2011, pp. 108–114). But we must understand that this practice was not universal, and monogamy was still the more common form of marriage even in those times.

In biblical times, polygamy served several practical purposes. It could ensure the continuation of a family line, especially in cases where the first wife was barren. It also provided economic security for women in a society where they had limited rights and opportunities outside of marriage. polygamy could serve political purposes, cementing alliances between families or tribes (Davidson, 2015, pp. 32–37).

The Mosaic Law, while not explicitly endorsing polygamy, did provide regulations for its practice. For instance, Deuteronomy 21:15-17 outlines inheritance rights in polygamous families, ensuring fair treatment of children from different wives. This suggests a pragmatic approach to an existing social reality rather than an endorsement of the practice (Preez, n.d.).

The presence of polygamy in biblical narratives does not necessarily imply divine approval. Rather, it reflects the cultural realities of the time, much as the Bible records other human practices that may not align with God’s ideal plan for humanity.

I urge us to see in these ancient practices a reflection of humanity’s journey towards understanding God’s will. The Bible, in its wisdom, does not shy away from depicting the complexities and imperfections of human relationships. Instead, it provides a narrative arc that gradually reveals God’s intentions for marriage and family.

In our modern context, we must be careful not to judge these ancient practices by our contemporary standards. Instead, we should seek to understand the historical and cultural context, while also discerning the timeless principles that God reveals through His Word (Ruff, 2023). This approach allows us to grow in wisdom and compassion, recognizing the journey of faith that has brought us to our current understanding of marriage and family.

Are there examples of polygamy in the Old Testament?

Perhaps the most well-known examples of polygamy in the Old Testament are found among the patriarchs and kings of Israel. Abraham, the father of faith, took Hagar as a second wife at the urging of his first wife, Sarah, who was barren. This decision, while culturally acceptable at the time, led to conflict and heartache within the family (Davidson, 2015, pp. 32–37).

Jacob, grandson of Abraham, famously married both Leah and Rachel, and later took their handmaidens Bilhah and Zilpah as concubines. His household was marked by rivalry and competition among the wives and their children, illustrating the emotional complexities of polygamous relationships (Preez, n.d.).

King David of God, had multiple wives and concubines. Yet, we see the tragic consequences of his desires when he takes Bathsheba, leading to adultery, murder, and familial strife. His son Solomon, renowned for his wisdom, is said to have had 700 wives and 300 concubines. The Bible notes that these foreign wives turned Solomon’s heart away from full devotion to God (Davidson, 2015, pp. 32–37).

Other examples include Elkanah, the father of Samuel, who had two wives, Hannah and Peninnah. The narrative poignantly describes the pain and rivalry between these women, particularly Hannah’s anguish over her initial barrenness (Preez, n.d.).

It’s crucial to understand, that Although the Old Testament records these instances of polygamy, it does not necessarily endorse the practice. Often, we see the negative consequences that arise from these arrangements – jealousy, favoritism, and family discord. These stories serve not as models to emulate, but as cautionary tales that reveal the human heart’s complexities and the challenges that arise when we deviate from God’s original design for marriage.

I invite you to consider these accounts with both empathy and discernment. The individuals in these stories were products of their time and culture, grappling with the realities of their world. Yet, through their struggles, we can discern God’s patient pedagogy, gradually revealing His perfect will for human relationships.

Despite these prominent examples, monogamy appears to have been the more common practice among the general population in ancient Israel. The examples of polygamy we see are often among the wealthy and powerful, who had the means to support multiple wives (Ruff, 2023).

Although the Old Testament provides numerous examples of polygamy, it does so within a larger narrative that ultimately points towards God’s ideal of monogamous, covenant love between one man and one woman. These accounts serve to illuminate the human condition, the consequences of our choices, and the gradual unfolding of God’s plan for marriage and family.

Does God approve of or condemn polygamy in the Bible?

In the Old Testament, we find that polygamy is neither explicitly condemned nor approved by God. The Mosaic Law, while regulating certain aspects of polygamous marriages, does not prohibit the practice outright. For instance, Deuteronomy 21:15-17 provides guidelines for inheritance in polygamous families, suggesting a pragmatic approach to an existing social reality rather than an endorsement (Preez, n.d.).

But it’s crucial to note that the absence of explicit condemnation does not equate to divine approval. Throughout the Old Testament narratives, we see the negative consequences that often accompany polygamous relationships – jealousy, favoritism, and family strife. These accounts serve as cautionary tales, revealing the challenges that arise when human arrangements deviate from God’s original design (Davidson, 2015, pp. 32–37).

The creation account in Genesis 2 presents a model of marriage between one man and one woman, which Jesus later affirms in the New Testament. This suggests that monogamy was God’s ideal from the beginning. The prophet Malachi also speaks of marriage in monogamous terms, criticizing those who are unfaithful to the “wife of your youth” (Malachi 2:14-15) (Ruff, 2023).

As we move into the New Testament, we find a clearer emphasis on monogamy as the Christian ideal for marriage. Jesus, in his teaching on divorce, refers back to the creation account, reinforcing the concept of two becoming one flesh (Matthew 19:4-6). The apostle Paul, in his letters, consistently uses singular terms when referring to a man’s wife, and lists monogamy as a qualification for church leadership (1 Timothy 3:2, Titus 1:6) (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427).

Psychologically we might understand God’s approach to polygamy in the Bible as a form of progressive revelation. Just as a wise parent gradually guides a child towards maturity, God patiently leads humanity towards a fuller understanding of His will for human relationships. This process takes into account the cultural and historical realities of each era while steadily moving towards the divine ideal.

I urge you to consider that while God may have tolerated polygamy in certain historical contexts, His ultimate design and desire for marriage is monogamous union. The overall trajectory of Scripture, from the creation account to the teachings of Jesus and the apostles, points towards this conclusion.

In our modern context, as we strive to live out God’s will for our lives and relationships, we are called to embrace the fullness of His revelation in Christ. This means upholding the dignity and equality of all persons within the covenant of marriage, reflecting the selfless love of Christ for His Church in our own marital commitments.

What does Jesus say about marriage and polygamy in the New Testament?

In the Gospel of Matthew, when questioned about divorce, Jesus refers back to the creation account in Genesis, saying, “Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’?” (Matthew 19:4-5) (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427). This reference to “two becoming one flesh” implicitly supports a monogamous understanding of marriage.

Jesus continues, “So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate” (Matthew 19:6). Here, our Lord emphasizes the permanence and sanctity of the marital bond, again using language that suggests a union between two individuals (Nyarko, 2023).

It’s major that when addressing marriage, Jesus consistently uses singular terms – “a man,” “his wife” – rather than language that might accommodate polygamous arrangements. This linguistic choice, while not an explicit condemnation of polygamy, aligns with a monogamous ideal (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427).

In the Gospel of Mark, Jesus reiterates these teachings, adding a strong statement against divorce: “Whoever divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery against her, and if she divorces her husband and marries another, she commits adultery” (Mark 10:11-12). This teaching, which treats husband and wife as equal partners with mutual obligations, is difficult to reconcile with polygamous practices (Nyarko, 2023).

Psychologically we might understand Jesus’ teachings on marriage as emphasizing the deep, intimate, and exclusive nature of the marital bond. His words point to a relationship of mutual self-giving and fidelity that finds its fullest expression in monogamous union.

In His interactions with women, Jesus consistently upheld their dignity and worth in a cultural context where they were often marginalized. This attitude aligns more closely with a monogamous understanding of marriage, where both partners are equally valued (Wong, 2017).

While Jesus does not explicitly prohibit polygamy, His teachings set a high standard for marital relationships that seems incompatible with polygamous practices. He points us back to God’s original intention in creation and forward to the Kingdom of God, where marriage itself will be transcended (Matthew 22:30).

I invite you to reflect deeply on these teachings of our Lord. They call us to a radical love and commitment in marriage that mirrors Christ’s own love for the Church. In our modern context, where equality and mutual respect are rightly valued, Jesus’ words continue to challenge and inspire us to live out God’s design for marriage in its fullest and most beautiful form.

How do Paul and other New Testament writers address polygamy?

The Apostle Paul, in his letters, consistently uses language that implies a monogamous understanding of marriage. In his powerful exposition on marriage in Ephesians 5, Paul speaks of the relationship between husband and wife as a reflection of Christ’s relationship with the Church. He states, “For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh” (Ephesians 5:31) (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427). This echoes Jesus’ own words and the creation account, reinforcing the idea of marriage as a union between two individuals.

In his pastoral letters, Paul lists monogamy as a qualification for church leadership. He writes that an elder or overseer should be “the husband of one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2, Titus 1:6). While some scholars debate whether this phrase prohibits polygamy or remarriage after divorce, it clearly presents monogamy as the expected norm for Christian leaders (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427).

The author of Hebrews also upholds the sanctity of monogamous marriage, stating, “Marriage should be honored by all, and the marriage bed kept pure” (Hebrews 13:4). This exhortation to marital fidelity is most naturally understood in the context of a monogamous relationship (Rordorf, 1969, pp. 193–210).

Peter, in his first epistle, addresses husbands and wives in terms that suggest a one-to-one relationship. He calls on husbands to be considerate of their wives and treat them with respect, again using singular terms that imply monogamy (1 Peter 3:7) (Thatcher, 2021, pp. 420–427).

Psychologically we might understand these New Testament teachings as promoting a view of marriage that emphasizes mutual love, respect, and fidelity. This aligns with the Christian understanding of human dignity and the equal worth of men and women as bearers of God’s image.

The early Christian communities were emerging in a Greco-Roman world where monogamy was the legal norm, even if extramarital relationships were common among men. The New Testament writers, while not explicitly condemning polygamy, present a vision of marriage that aligns more closely with monogamous practice (Rordorf, 1969, pp. 193–210).

I urge us to see in these teachings a call to the highest ideals of marital love and commitment. The New Testament writers, building on the foundation of Jesus’ teachings, present marriage as a sacred covenant that reflects Christ’s own sacrificial love for the Church.

In our modern context, where we strive to build relationships based on mutual respect and equality, these New Testament teachings continue to offer powerful guidance. They challenge us to view marriage not as a mere social contract, but as a divine calling to love and serve one another in a way that glorifies God and witnesses to His love for the world.

What did the early Church Fathers teach about polygamy?

From the earliest days of the there was a clear emphasis on monogamy as the ideal form of marriage. This view was rooted in the teachings of Jesus Christ and the apostles, who reaffirmed the original design of marriage as a union between one man and one woman. The Church Fathers, building upon this foundation, consistently taught that polygamy was incompatible with Christian marriage.

Justin Martyr, writing in the second century, affirmed that Christians either married only once or remained celibate. He saw monogamy as a reflection of God’s relationship with the Church. Irenaeus of Lyons, another prominent second-century figure, criticized those who practiced polygamy, viewing it as a departure from God’s original plan for marriage.

As we move into the third and fourth centuries, we find even more explicit condemnations of polygamy. Tertullian, though later embracing a more rigorist stance, argued forcefully against polygamy, seeing it as a violation of the natural order established by God. Augustine of Hippo, one of the most influential Church Fathers, wrote extensively on marriage and firmly rejected polygamy as inconsistent with Christian teaching.

The Church Fathers were not merely imposing arbitrary rules. Their teachings on monogamy were deeply rooted in their understanding of Scripture and the nature of God’s love. They saw marriage as a sacred symbol of Christ’s relationship with the and polygamy as a distortion of this beautiful image.

But we must also acknowledge the historical context in which these teachings emerged. The early Church was spreading in a world where polygamy was practiced in various cultures. The Fathers had to address this reality pastorally while upholding the Christian ideal of marriage. They recognized the complexity of situations where converts to Christianity were already in polygamous marriages, often advocating for compassionate approaches while still maintaining the norm of monogamy for new marriages.

I see in these teachings a powerful understanding of human nature and divine love. The Church Fathers recognized that monogamy provides the best environment for the mutual self-giving and fidelity that reflect God’s covenant love. Their consistent witness on this matter has shaped Christian teaching on marriage for centuries, guiding the faithful towards a deeper understanding of God’s plan for human relationships.

Why did some biblical figures practice polygamy if it’s wrong?

We must recognize that the Bible, while divinely inspired, also reflects the historical and cultural realities of its time. In the ancient Near East, polygamy was a common practice, particularly among rulers and wealthy individuals. The biblical narratives often describe rather than prescribe, showing us the reality of human lives with all their complexities and imperfections.

Many of the patriarchs and kings we encounter in the Old Testament, such as Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon, practiced polygamy. But it is crucial to note that the Bible does not present their polygamous relationships as ideal or without consequences. In fact, we often see the painful results of these arrangements – jealousy, favoritism, and family strife.

Psychologically we might understand the practice of polygamy in these biblical accounts as reflecting human weaknesses – the desire for status, the quest for male heirs, or the misguided attempt to solve problems through multiple marriages. These motivations, while understandable in their historical context, often led to complications and sorrows that the biblical narratives do not shy away from portraying.

It’s important to remember, that God’s revelation to humanity has been progressive. The full revelation of God’s plan for marriage, as exemplified in the creation account and later affirmed by Jesus, was not always clearly understood or followed in earlier times. God, in His infinite patience and mercy, worked within human cultural frameworks to gradually lead His people to a higher understanding of His will.

We see in the Bible a clear trajectory towards monogamy. As we move from the patriarchal narratives to the wisdom literature and the prophets, we find an increasing emphasis on the beauty and sanctity of monogamous love. The Song of Songs, for instance, celebrates the exclusive love between one man and one woman. The prophet Malachi strongly condemns unfaithfulness in marriage, pointing towards a monogamous ideal.

In the New Testament, Jesus reaffirms the original creation plan of one man and one woman united in marriage. The apostle Paul, in his teachings on marriage, consistently uses language that assumes monogamy as the norm for Christian marriage.

I see in these biblical accounts not a justification for polygamy, but rather a testament to God’s patience and grace in dealing with human frailty. These stories remind us that God works through imperfect people and situations to accomplish His purposes. They also serve as cautionary tales, showing us the pain and discord that can result when we deviate from God’s ideal plan for human relationships.

While some biblical figures practiced polygamy, reflecting the cultural norms of their time, the overall arc of Scripture points us towards monogamy as God’s intended design for marriage. Let us learn from these accounts, not to justify polygamy, but to appreciate God’s grace and to strive more earnestly to align our lives with His perfect will.

Is monogamy God’s ideal for marriage according to Scripture?

As we journey through the Old Testament, we encounter numerous passages that reinforce this monogamous ideal. The beautiful poetry of the Song of Songs celebrates the exclusive love between one man and one woman. The prophet Malachi speaks powerfully against marital unfaithfulness, reminding us that God is witness to the covenant between a man and “the wife of your youth” (Malachi 2:14).

In the wisdom literature, we find further affirmation of monogamy. Proverbs 5:18-19 exhorts, “Let your fountain be blessed, and rejoice in the wife of your youth.” The use of singular terms – “wife” rather than “wives” – is major and consistent throughout these teachings.

When we come to the New Testament, we see Jesus himself reaffirming the creation ideal of monogamy. In Matthew 19:4-6, our Lord quotes the Genesis passage and adds, “What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.” This teaching leaves no room for polygamy in God’s perfect plan for marriage.

The Apostle Paul, in his letters, consistently uses language that assumes monogamy as the norm for Christian marriage. In Ephesians 5:31, he quotes the Genesis passage about leaving father and mother and being united to one’s wife. Throughout his teachings on marriage, Paul speaks of “husband” and “wife” in the singular.

Psychologically we can see how monogamy aligns with our deepest needs for intimacy, trust, and exclusive commitment. God, in His wisdom, designed marriage as a reflection of His own faithful love for His people. Just as God is faithful to us, so are we called to be faithful to one spouse.

I am aware that polygamy was practiced in many ancient cultures, including among some figures in the Old Testament. But we must understand these accounts as descriptive rather than prescriptive. The Bible often shows us the reality of human lives, with all their complexities and imperfections, while still pointing us towards God’s higher ideal.

We see in Scripture a clear progression towards monogamy. As God’s revelation unfolds through history, the ideal of monogamous marriage becomes increasingly clear. By the time of the New Testament, monogamy is unequivocally presented as the Christian standard for marriage.

Although we must approach this topic with pastoral sensitivity, recognizing the complexities of human relationships and cultural contexts, the weight of biblical evidence clearly points to monogamy as God’s ideal for marriage. This understanding is not a burden, but a beautiful gift – an invitation to participate in a relationship that reflects God’s faithful love for His people.

How should Christians view polygamy in other cultures today?

We must affirm that as Christians, our primary allegiance is to Christ and His teachings. The New Testament clearly presents monogamy as the ideal for Christian marriage, reflecting the relationship between Christ and His Church. This understanding should shape our perspective on marriage, regardless of cultural contexts.

But we must also recognize the reality of diverse cultural practices around the world. In some societies, polygamy has been a longstanding tradition, often intertwined with complex social, economic, and religious factors. As Christians engaging with these cultures, we are called to be both faithful to biblical teaching and sensitive to the challenges faced by those in polygamous relationships.

Historically we can see parallels with the early Church’s encounter with polygamy in the Greco-Roman and Jewish worlds. The apostles and early Church fathers had to navigate these cultural realities while upholding the Christian ideal of monogamy. Their approach was generally to maintain monogamy as the standard for new converts, while dealing graciously with existing polygamous families.

I am aware of the potential emotional and relational complexities within polygamous families. While some may argue that polygamy can provide economic security or address issues of gender imbalance in certain societies, it often leads to jealousy, favoritism, and the objectification of women. These dynamics can hinder the mutual self-giving love that is at the heart of Christian marriage.

In our approach to polygamy in other cultures, we must be guided by several key principles:

1. Uphold the biblical ideal: We should clearly teach and model monogamy as God’s design for marriage.
2. Show compassion: We must approach those in polygamous relationships with love and understanding, recognizing the cultural and personal factors that have shaped their lives.
3. Promote human dignity: Our response should always affirm the equal worth and dignity of all individuals, particularly women who may be marginalized in polygamous systems.
4. Support gradual transformation: Although we cannot condone polygamy, we should work towards a gradual, culturally sensitive transformation of marriage practices, rather than demanding immediate, potentially disruptive changes.
5. Provide pastoral care: We must offer support and guidance to those transitioning out of polygamous relationships, ensuring that all family members are cared for.

As we engage with this issue, we should also be mindful of the beam in our own eye. Many societies that historically practiced monogamy now struggle with serial monogamy, infidelity, and the breakdown of family structures. Our witness on marriage must be holistic, addressing not just the form but the quality and commitment of marital relationships.

Although we must unequivocally uphold monogamy as God’s design for marriage, our approach to polygamy in other cultures should be characterized by grace, wisdom, and a deep commitment to the dignity of all people. Let us pray for guidance as we seek to be faithful witnesses of Christ’s love in a complex and diverse world.

What are the main arguments for and against polygamy from a biblical perspective?

Arguments often presented in favor of polygamy from a biblical perspective include:

1. Old Testament examples: Proponents point to the fact that several prominent figures in the Old Testament, including Abraham, Jacob, David, and Solomon, practiced polygamy without explicit divine condemnation.
2. Absence of direct prohibition: Some argue that there is no clear, universal prohibition of polygamy in the Bible, particularly in the Old Testament.
3. Cultural accommodation: It is suggested that God tolerated polygamy as a cultural practice of the time, much like divorce, which Jesus later addressed as not being God’s original intention.
4. Procreation emphasis: In the context of the Old Testament’s emphasis on procreation and continuing family lines, some argue that polygamy served a purpose in ensuring offspring.

But the arguments against polygamy from a biblical perspective are more numerous and, in my view, more compelling:

1. Creation ideal: Genesis 2:24 establishes the pattern of one man and one woman becoming “one flesh,” which Jesus reaffirms in Matthew 19:4-6.
2. Symbolic significance: The monogamous marriage relationship is used throughout Scripture as a symbol of God’s relationship with His people, most notably in Ephesians 5:31-32.
3. New Testament teaching: The consistent use of singular terms for “husband” and “wife” in New Testament passages about marriage implies a monogamous norm.
4. Qualifications for church leaders: The requirement for elders and deacons to be “the husband of one wife” (1 Timothy 3:2, 12; Titus 1:6) suggests monogamy as the Christian standard.
5. Negative consequences: The Old Testament narratives often show the negative consequences of polygamy, including jealousy, favoritism, and family strife.
6. Progressive revelation: There is a clear trajectory in Scripture towards monogamy, culminating in the New Testament’s unequivocal presentation of monogamous marriage.
7. Equality and dignity: Monogamy better reflects the equal dignity of men and women created in God’s image.

Psychologically we can see how monogamy provides a more stable environment for emotional intimacy and family cohesion. The exclusive commitment between two individuals fosters trust, security, and mutual self-giving that reflect God’s faithful love.

Historically, we observe that while polygamy was practiced in many ancient cultures, including among some Israelites, it was never the norm for the majority. as God’s revelation progressed, we see an increasing emphasis on monogamy, particularly in the prophetic and wisdom literature.

The presence of polygamy in biblical narratives does not equate to divine approval. Often, these accounts serve as cautionary tales, showing the complications and sorrows that arise from deviating from God’s ideal plan.

I believe the weight of biblical evidence clearly favors monogamy as God’s design for marriage. The isolated examples of polygamy in Scripture, when viewed in the context of the entire biblical narrative, do not override the consistent teaching on monogamous marriage as the divine ideal.

Although we must approach this issue with compassion for those in different cultural contexts, we are called to uphold the beauty and sanctity of monogamous marriage. Let us strive to reflect God’s faithful love in our own relationships, always seeking to align our lives with His perfect will.

—