Compare Christian Denominations
Amish and Mennonite compared
God and the Bible
Trinity
Amish
we confess with the mouth, and believe with the heart, with all the pious, according to the holy Scriptures, in one eternal, almighty, and incomprehensible God, the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, and in none more, nor in any other;
Mennonite
To confess that God is Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is to confess that the Son and the Holy Spirit are fully divine. It is also to confess that God is one and that God’s oneness is the unity of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 1 (commentary)
Authority
Amish
The Amish endorse basic Christian beliefs, but their spirituality has been shaped by their interpretation of the Bible as well as several written sources.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Beliefs
Mennonite
We acknowledge the Scripture as the authoritative source and standard for preaching and teaching about faith and life, for distinguishing truth from error, for discerning between good and evil, and for guiding prayer and worship.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 4
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
Revelation today
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
We also believe and confess that before His ascension He instituted His New Testament, and, since it was to be and remain an eternal Testament, that He confirmed and sealed the same with His precious blood, and gave and left it to His disciples, yea, charged them so highly with it, that neither angel nor man may alter it, nor add to it nor take away from it;
Mennonite
We believe that God continues to speak through the living and written Word.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 4
Books of the Bible
Amish
The Amish read the whole Christian Bible, Old Testament and New, in Luther's German translation for worship.
From our article Are the Amish Jewish? No: Amish and Jewish Faith Compared
Mennonite
We recognize the 39 books of the Old Testament and the 27 books of New Testament as belonging to inspired Scripture.
How the Bible was written
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Amish people are more concerned about practicing their faith than teaching formal theological doctrines, however. Following the lead of their Swiss Anabaptist forbears, the Amish seek to follow the teachings of Jesus in daily life by loving their enemies and forgiving insults.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Beliefs
Mennonite
We believe that God was at work through the centuries in the process by which the books of the Old and New Testaments were inspired and written.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 4
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
How the Bible was kept
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
In addition to Luther’s German Bible, the Martyrs Mirror, the Ausbund, and the Dordrecht Confession of Faith are key sources for their beliefs.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Beliefs
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
The Old Testament, the Gospels, the Pauline letters, and gradually the rest of the New Testament were broadly recognized by the church as Holy Scripture by the fourth century.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 4 (commentary)
Bible without error
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Amish people are more concerned about practicing their faith than teaching formal theological doctrines, however. Following the lead of their Swiss Anabaptist forbears, the Amish seek to follow the teachings of Jesus in daily life by loving their enemies and forgiving insults.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Beliefs
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
We also acknowledge the Scripture as the fully reliable and trustworthy Word of God written in human language.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 4
Creation
Amish
Of this same one God, who works all in all, we believe and confess that He is the Creator of all things visible and invisible; that He, in six days, created, made, and prepared, heaven and earth, and the sea, and all that in them is;
Mennonite
Of this same one God, who works all in all, we believe and confess that He is the Creator of all things visible and invisible; that He, in six days, created, made, and prepared, heaven and earth, and the sea, and all that in them is; and that He still governs and upholds the same and all His works through His wisdom, might, and the word of His power.
From Dordrecht Confession (1632), Article I, Of God and the Creation of All Things
The Holy Spirit's origin
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
we confess with the mouth, and believe with the heart, with all the pious, according to the holy Scriptures, in one eternal, almighty, and incomprehensible God, the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, and in none more, nor in any other;
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
We believe in the Holy Spirit, who was sent by the Father and the Son to bring to individuals the redemption of Christ.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 1, The Holy Spirit
Salvation
Salvation
Amish
we must go to God with an upright heart, and in perfect faith, and believe in Jesus Christ, as the Scripture says, and testifies of Him; through which faith we obtain forgiveness of sins, are sanctified, justified, and made children of God
Mennonite
We place our faith in God that, by the same power that raised Christ from the dead, we may be saved from sin to follow Christ in this life and to know the fullness of salvation in the age to come.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 8
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
Losing salvation
Amish
when any one, after he is enlightened, has accepted the knowledge of the truth, and been incorporated into the communion of the saints, sins again unto death, either through willfulness, or through presumption against God, or through some other cause, and falls into the unfruitful works of darkness, thereby becoming separated from God, and forfeiting the kingdom of God
Mennonite
If disobedience persists, the church may withhold the right to commune until the individual repents. And the church must, with a deep sense of loss, recognize that the one who goes on to full apostasy and spiritual ruin has severed his relation with Christ and His body.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 8, Discipline
God's choosing
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
And that thus the Son of God died, and tasted death and shed His precious blood for all men;
Mennonite
From all eternity God knew who would be the believers in Christ, and these persons foreknown as believers are elect according to the foreknowledge of God.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 6, Salvation by Grace Through Faith
Who is saved
Amish
excluding no one from the precious inheritance of eternal salvation, except the unbelieving and disobedient, the stiff-necked and obdurate, who despise it, and incur this through their own sins, thus making themselves unworthy of eternal life.
Mennonite
We believe that, through the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, God offers salvation from sin and a new way of life to all people. We receive God’s salvation when we repent of sin and accept Jesus Christ as Savior and Lord.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 8, Salvation (mennoniteusa.org)
Our article: Do Catholics Believe in Predestination? What Each Church Teaches
Original sin
Amish
through which disobedience sin has come into the world, and death by sin, which has thus passed upon all men, for that all have sinned, and, hence, brought upon themselves the wrath of God, and condemnation;
Mennonite
Although men are sinners by nature because of Adam's fall, they are not guilty of his sin. Those who perish eternally do so only because of their own sin.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 4, Man and His Sin
Our article: Original Sin: What Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants Each Teach
Human nature
Amish
We believe and confess, that, since the imagination of man's heart is evil from his youth, and, therefore, prone to all unrighteousness, sin, and wickedness, the first lesson of the precious New Testament of the Son of God is repentance and reformation of life,
Mennonite
We confess that, beginning with Adam and Eve, humanity has disobeyed God, given way to the tempter, and chosen to sin.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 7
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
Holiness in this life
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
those who have ears to hear, and hearts to understand, must bring forth genuine fruits of repentance, reform their lives, believe the Gospel, eschew evil and do good, desist from unrighteousness, forsake sin, put off the old man with his deeds, and put on the new man, which after God is created in righteousness and true holiness:
Mennonite
As long as the believer lives, he stands in need of the forgiveness, cleansing, and grace of Christ.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 6, Salvation by Grace Through Faith
Old Testament law
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Concerning the swearing of oaths we believe and confess that the Lord Christ has set aside and forbidden the same to His disciples, that they should not swear at all, but that yea should be yea, and nay, nay;
Mennonite
We believe that the Old Testament and the New Testament together constitute the Word of God, that the Old Covenant was preparatory, that its institutions were temporary in character, and that the New Covenant in Christ is the fulfillment of the Old.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 2, Divine Revelation
Baptism and Communion
Baptism
Amish
Baptism shall be given to all those who have learned repentance and amendment of life, and who believe truly that their sins are taken away by Christ,
From Schleitheim Articles (1527), article I
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
Baptism is for those who are of the age of accountability and who freely request baptism on the basis of their response to Jesus Christ in faith.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 11
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
How baptism is done
Amish
The Amish practice baptism by pouring or affusion, rather than by full immersion.
From our article Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
Since baptism with the Holy Spirit is a pouring out, we generally practice pouring as our mode of water baptism.
Receiving the Spirit
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
penitent believers, who, through faith, regeneration, and the renewing of the Holy Ghost, are made one with God, and are written in heaven, must, upon such Scriptural confession of faith, and renewing of life, be baptized with water,
Mennonite
By water and the Spirit, we are born anew into the family of God. The Spirit dwells in each child of God, bringing us into relationship with God. Through the indwelling of the Spirit, we are made heirs together with Christ, if we suffer with him, so that we may also be glorified with him.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 3
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
Baptism for the dead
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
As Anabaptists, the Amish place supreme importance on adult baptism. Those who take the baptismal vow commit themselves to following the ways of Jesus and upholding the Ordnung of the church for life.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Rituals
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Baptism is for those who are of the age of accountability and who freely request baptism on the basis of their response to Jesus Christ in faith.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 11, Baptism (mennoniteusa.org)
Communion
Amish
We also confess and observe the breaking of bread, or Supper, as the Lord Christ Jesus before His suffering instituted it with bread and wine, and observed and ate with His apostles, commanding them to observe it in remembrance of Him;
From Dordrecht Confession of Faith (1632), article X
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
We believe that the Lord’s Supper is a sign by which the church thankfully remembers the new covenant which Jesus established by his death. In this communion meal, the members of the church renew our covenant with God and with each other.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 12
Our article: Quaker vs. Mennonite Beliefs
Who takes Communion
Amish
All those who wish to break one bread in remembrance of the broken body of Christ, and all who wish to drink of one drink as a remembrance of the shed blood of Christ, shall be united beforehand by baptism in one body of Christ which is the church of God and whose Head is Christ.
From Schleitheim Articles (1527), article III
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
All are invited to the Lord’s table who have been baptized into the community of faith, are living at peace with God and with their brothers and sisters in the faith, and are willing to be accountable in their congregation.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 12
Communion bread and wine
Amish
We also confess and observe the breaking of bread, or Supper, as the Lord Christ Jesus before His suffering instituted it with bread and wine,
Mennonite
The bread of the Lord’s Supper is a sign of Christ’s body, and the cup is a sign of the new covenant in his blood
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 12 (commentary)
Sacraments
Amish
neither baptism, supper, church [membership], nor any other outward ceremony, can without faith, regeneration, change or renewing of life, avail anything to please God or to obtain of Him any consolation or promise of salvation;
Mennonite
The Lord Jesus and His apostles instituted ordinances for the church to observe permanently as symbols of Christian truths. The apostolic church literally observed them.
Church and worship
Leadership
Amish
No central organization or national church authority holds the subgroups together. Most districts in an affiliation have similar practices, but even so the ultimate authority for Amish life and practice lies in the local district.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Organization
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
We believe Scripture teaches that God has delegated leadership in the church to men. At the time of ministerial ordinations, if there is more than one qualifying brother we believe the use of the lot is a biblical means of finding God's choice.
From Keystone Mennonite Fellowship, 1998 supplement to the Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963)
Who may be ordained
Amish
Ordained officials, literally called “servants” in the Pennsylvania German dialect, normally serve for life. None has formal theological training—living a consistent Amish way of life is their most important credential. Although they may receive occasional gifts of food, the leaders are not paid for their church work and must support themselves by other occupations.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Leadership
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
We believe Scripture teaches that God has delegated leadership in the church to men. At the time of ministerial ordinations, if there is more than one qualifying brother we believe the use of the lot is a biblical means of finding God's choice.
From Keystone Mennonite Fellowship, 1998 supplement to the Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963)
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Women ministers
Amish
Each church district has its own leaders—always men. Typically, the leaders include a bishop (servant with full powers), two or three ministers (servants of the book), and a deacon (servant to the poor).
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Leadership
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
The church calls, trains, and appoints gifted men and women to a variety of leadership ministries on its behalf. These may include such offices as pastor, deacon, and elder as well as evangelists, missionaries, teachers, conference ministers, and overseers.
From Mennonite Church USA, Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 15
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Confession
Amish
Members confess their sins and reaffirm their vow to uphold the Ordnung at a council meeting held prior to the communion service.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Rituals
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
Confessing our sins to one another and receiving forgiveness, we are to come as one body to the table of the Lord.
Our article: Confession: Which Churches Confess to a Priest?
Day of worship
Amish
Because the Amish do not have church buildings, they hold church services in their homes. Every other Sunday, the members of the local district meet in the home of one of their members.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Services
Mennonite
We believe that the principle of resting from secular work one day out of seven is intended for all time. We believe that the Lord's Day should be kept as a day of devotion and worship, and that everyone should regularly attend church services and Sunday School whenever possible.
From Keystone Mennonite Fellowship, 1998 supplement to the Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963)
Worship music
Amish
Slow, unison singing in German, without rhythm or instruments, unites the community together in worship. The ancient tunes are sung by memory.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Services
Our article: Amish Religious Practices: How Do The Amish Worship?
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Spiritual disciplines such as prayer, study of Scripture, reflection on God, corporate worship, singing hymns, simplicity, witness, and service are training in godliness.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 18
Icons and images
Amish
Religious services reflect the simplicity and plainness of Amish life. There are no altars, candles, organs, stained glass windows, choirs, or pulpits.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Services
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Neither the work of human hands, nor the forces of the natural world around us, nor the power of the nations among which we live are worthy of the trust and honor due the Creator on whom they depend.
Speaking in tongues
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
A scripture passage, read by the deacon, and two prayers (one silent and the other read from a prayer book), during which the congregation kneels, are part of the lengthy service.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Religious Services
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
By water and the Spirit, we are born anew into the family of God. The Spirit dwells in each child of God, bringing us into relationship with God.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 3, Holy Spirit (mennoniteusa.org)
Spiritual gifts today
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
each may minister unto the other with the gift he has received of the Lord, so that through mutual service and the assistance of every member, each in his measure, the body of Christ may be improved
Mennonite
By the gifts of the Holy Spirit, all Christians are called to carry out their particular ministries. By the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the church comes to unity in doctrine and action. By the power of the Holy Spirit, the church preaches, teaches, testifies, heals, loves, and suffers, following the example of Jesus its Lord.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 3, Holy Spirit (mennoniteusa.org)
Our article: Cessationism: Did the Spiritual Gifts End? What Churches Teach
Demons and exorcism
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
the Son of God died, and tasted death and shed His precious blood for all men; and that He thereby bruised the serpent's head, destroyed the works of the devil, annulled the handwriting and obtained forgiveness of sins for all mankind
Mennonite
The more we sin, the more we become trapped in sin. By our sin we open ourselves to the bondage of demonic powers.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 7, Sin (mennoniteusa.org)
Our article: Demons and Exorcism: What Each Church Teaches
Head coverings
Amish
Women are expected to wear a head covering and, usually, a three-piece dress that includes a cape and an apron.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Regulations
Mennonite
The New Testament symbols of man's headship are to be his short hair and uncovered head while praying or prophesying, and the symbols of woman's role are her long hair and her veiled head.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), article 14, as printed by Keystone Mennonite Fellowship
Mary and the saints
Mary
Amish
He was conceived in the virgin Mary, who was espoused to a man named Joseph, of the house of David; and that she brought Him forth as her first-born son, at Bethlehem, wrapped Him in swaddling clothes, and laid Him in a manger
Mennonite
the Word, Himself became flesh and man; that He was conceived in the virgin Mary, who was espoused to a man named Joseph, of the house of David; and that she brought Him forth as her first-born son, at Bethlehem, wrapped Him in swaddling clothes, and laid Him in a manger.
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Was Mary sinless
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
sin has come into the world, and death by sin, which has thus passed upon all men, for that all have sinned, and, hence, brought upon themselves the wrath of God, and condemnation
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
as to how and in what manner this precious body was prepared, and how the Word became flesh, and He Himself man, in regard to this we content ourselves with the statement pertaining to this matter which the worthy evangelists have left us in their accounts
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Praying to saints
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
we confess with all the saints, that He is the Son of the living God, in whom alone consist all our hope, consolation, redemption, and salvation, which we neither may nor must seek in any other.
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
As faithful high priest, he has made the final atonement for sin and now intercedes for us.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 2, Jesus Christ (mennoniteusa.org)
Death and the end
After death
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
in the last day all men who shall have died, and fallen asleep, shall be awaked and quickened, and shall rise again, through the incomprehensible power of God
Mennonite
The New Testament says much about the resurrection. It speaks much less frequently and clearly about the state of persons between the time of their deaths and the resurrection. Yet, we who are in Christ are assured that not even death can separate us from the love of God (Rom. 8:38-39).
Purgatory
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
everyone shall receive in his own body according to that he hath done, whether it be good or evil
Mennonite
We believe that at death the righteous enter at once into conscious joy and fellowship with Christ, while the wicked are in a state of conscious suffering.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 20, The Final Consummation
Hell
Amish
the wicked or impious, as accursed, shall be cast into outer darkness, yea, into the everlasting pains of hell, where their worm shall not die, nor their fire be quenched, and where they, according to holy Scripture, can nevermore expect any hope, comfort, or redemption.
Mennonite
The righteous will rise to eternal life with God, and the unrighteous to hell and separation from God.
The rapture
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
those who then will still be alive, and who shall be changed in the twinkling of an eye, at the sound of the last trump, shall be placed before the judgment seat of Christ, and the good be separated from the wicked
Mennonite
In His triumphant Second Coming Christ will judge Satan, and usher in the consummation of all things. His coming will introduce the resurrection, the transformation of the living saints, the judgment of the just and the unjust, and the fulfillment of His glorious reign.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 20, The Final Consummation
Our article: Which Denominations Believe in the Rapture?
The Tribulation
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
He sits on the right hand of God the Majesty on high, whence He will come again to judge the quick and the dead.
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
Jesus counseled his followers against trying to set dates for the coming age (Matt. 24:36). We should also be cautious about too narrowly identifying persons, places, or events of the end times with particular people, places, and happenings of the present.
The thousand years
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
the good or pious, as the blessed, shall be taken up with Christ, and shall enter into life eternal, and obtain that joy, which eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither hath entered into the heart of man, to reign and triumph with Christ forever and ever.
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
We believe in God’s final victory, in the end of this present age of struggle between good and evil, in the resurrection of the dead, and in the appearance of a new heaven and a new earth. There the people of God will reign with Christ in justice, righteousness, and peace.
Dispensations
Amish
Amish has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
came into the world, not to bruise, break, or destroy the souls of men, but to heal and restore them, to seek the lost, to break down the middle wall of partition, to make of twain one, and thus to gather of Jews, Gentiles, and all nations, one flock, for a church in His name
Mennonite
Today the spiritual "seed of Abraham" are those who have faith in Christ, the people of God, the body of Christ, composed of believers from all races and nations.
From Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963), Article 8, The Church of Christ
Our article: What Is Dispensationalism? Which Churches Hold It or Reject It
Marriage and family
Marriage
Amish
We confess that there is in the church of God an honorable state of matrimony, of two free, believing persons, in accordance with the manner after which God originally ordained the same in Paradise, and instituted it Himself with Adam and Eve
Mennonite
We believe that God intends marriage to be a covenant between one man and one woman for life.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 19
Sex outside marriage
Amish
Sexual relations before marriage are strongly discouraged, but occasionally fast-track weddings occur because of an impending pregnancy. Unmarried people of the opposite sex never live together, and divorce is forbidden.
From Donald B. Kraybill, Questions About the Amish, no. 7 (PBS American Experience, 2012)
Mennonite
According to Scripture, right sexual union takes place only within the marriage relationship.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective (1995), Article 19, Marriage (mennoniteusa.org)
Divorce
Amish
As part of their Ordnung, Old Order Amish forbid owning automobiles; tapping electricity from public utility lines; owning televisions, radios, or personal computers; attending high school or college; joining the military; and initiating divorce.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Regulations
Our article: Can the Amish Get Divorced? No, Their Church Forbids It
Mennonite
We believe God designed marriage to be a permanent, sacred bond between one man and one woman, terminated only by death. Remarriage after divorce constitutes adultery and comes under the wrath of God.
From Keystone Mennonite Fellowship, 1998 supplement to the Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963)
Remarriage
Amish
Amish churches forbid their members to seek a divorce or to remarry while a husband or wife is still living, and a member who does either faces excommunication and shunning.
From our article Can the Amish Get Divorced? No, Their Church Forbids It
Mennonite
Remarriage after divorce constitutes adultery and comes under the wrath of God. Anyone married to and living with one divorced while the former partner is still living cannot be received into church membership.
From Keystone Mennonite Fellowship, 1998 supplement to the Mennonite Confession of Faith (1963)
Contraception
Amish
The teaching leaves the number of children to God; the practice varies. Lawrence Greksa of Case Western Reserve University describes the Amish as having "long-standing religious-based proscriptions against birth control."
From our article Amish Marriage and Children: Wedding Age, Family Size and Birth Customs
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
We support responsible decisions to limit family size. We believe that when pregnancy is not desired, responsible men and women will take responsibility for their sexual behavior.
Abortion
Amish
Abortion is universally forbidden.
From Anderson and Potts, The Amish Health Culture, Social Science & Medicine (2020)
Mennonite
Human life is a gift from God to be valued and protected. We oppose abortion because it runs counter to biblical principles. The fetus in its earliest stages (and even if imperfect by human standards) shares humanity with those who conceived it.
From Mennonite Church USA, Statement on Abortion (2003), II. We believe
Life and conscience
Blood transfusions
Amish
There are no explicit religious prohibitions against certain types of medicine. The use of modern medicine varies greatly from family to family and group to group.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Frequently Asked Questions
Our article: Can the Amish Become Doctors? No, but They Use Doctors and Hospitals
Mennonite
Mennonite has no teaching on this exact question. The closest is:
In response to the prayer of faith, and in accordance with His will, God heals in various ways, through the use of medicine, and the medical profession or by direct intervention.
Alcohol
Amish
Some Amish drink alcohol, but far less than their neighbors, and Amish churches discourage it. Practice differs by affiliation: New Order Amish churches set out to end drinking, while surveys in Ohio find some Amish adults who drink. Wine is served at Amish communion, and most reported heavy drinking is among young people before baptism.
From our article Do the Amish Drink Alcohol?
Mennonite
They regard their bodies as temples of the Holy Spirit and crucify their flesh with its affections and lusts. They therefore avoid such things as harmful drugs, beverage alcohol, and tobacco.
War and military service
Amish
As regards revenge, that is, to oppose an enemy with the sword, we believe and confess that the Lord Christ has forbidden and set aside to His disciples and followers all revenge and retaliation, and commanded them to render to no one evil for evil, or cursing for cursing, but to put the sword into the sheath
Mennonite
As disciples of Christ, we do not prepare for war, or participate in war or military service.
From Confession of Faith in a Mennonite Perspective, article 22
Our article: Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Read the full comparison Amish vs Mennonite: Same Anabaptist Roots, Different Ways of Living
Your comparison is on its way
Look for it in your inbox in the next few minutes.
Each answer is quoted word for word from the church’s own documents, with a link to the page it came from. Where we found no official statement, the cell says so.
TopAbout this comparison
What this shows
23 Christian churches and traditions set side by side on 55 questions, each answer quoted from the church’s own statement of what it teaches, with a link to the page it came from.
Use it in church or class
Free to use in your church or class. Print the chart, project it or copy from it without asking. If you publish it, please credit Christian Pure. A plain-text credit is enough.
Our own summaries, and the list of which document answers which question, are released by Christian Pure under CC BY 4.0. You may link to us or not, and any link may carry nofollow. The quoted words belong to the churches that wrote them and are not part of that release, so the spreadsheet lists each source and leaves the quotations out.
Cite this page
Christian Pure. "Compare Christian Denominations." Updated November 9, 2026. https://christianpure.com/compare-denominations/.
Made by the Christian Pure editorial team. Last updated . Found a mistake? Tell us, and see the corrections log.
