Amish and Quakers are often confused because both were once called Plain people and both refuse to fight. The Amish grew out of a sixteenth-century movement on the Continent and the Quakers out of seventeenth-century England, and they hold almost opposite convictions about how God speaks.
To see what the Amish and Mennonites teach beside what Quakers teach on 55 questions, open our free tool, Compare Christian Denominations.

The short version
| Amish | Quakers | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Swiss and Alsatian Anabaptists; split from the Mennonites in 1693 | England, 1650s, around George Fox |
| Founder | Jakob Ammann | George Fox |
| Authority | Scripture, read and applied by the congregation | The inward light — God speaking directly to each person |
| Worship | Preaching and hymns, in homes, in Pennsylvania Dutch German | Traditionally silent, until someone is moved to speak |
| Clergy | Ministers chosen by lot from the congregation, unpaid | None in the traditional form; many US churches now have pastors |
| Sacraments | Adult baptism and communion | None — the outward forms are held to be unnecessary |
| Dress | Plain, prescribed by the local Ordnung | Plain historically; almost entirely abandoned |
| Technology | Limited by community decision | No restriction |
| Numbers | Growing fast — large families, high retention | Small and declining in Britain; larger evangelical bodies elsewhere |
Where the Amish and Quakers differ
Each answer is quoted from the church’s own documents or from one of our articles.
Authority
Amish
The Amish endorse basic Christian beliefs, but their spirituality has been shaped by their interpretation of the Bible as well as several written sources.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Beliefs
Quaker (Friends)
so they testify that the Spirit is that Guide by which the saints are led into all truth: therefore, according to the Scriptures the Spirit is the first and principal Leader.
From Quaker faith & practice (Britain Yearly Meeting) 27.28, Robert Barclay, 1678
Who is saved
Amish
excluding no one from the precious inheritance of eternal salvation, except the unbelieving and disobedient, the stiff-necked and obdurate, who despise it, and incur this through their own sins, thus making themselves unworthy of eternal life.
Quaker (Friends)
From the beginning the Quaker Christian faith has had a universal dimension. George Fox saw the Light ‘shine through all’ and he identified it with the divine Light of Christ that ‘enlightens every man that comes into the world’ (John 1:9).
Baptism
Amish
Baptism shall be given to all those who have learned repentance and amendment of life, and who believe truly that their sins are taken away by Christ,
Quaker (Friends)
It is the inward change, the inward purification, the spiritual fact and not the outward symbol, that belongs in truth to the Kingdom of God.
From Quaker faith & practice (Britain Yearly Meeting) 27.37, John Wilhelm Rowntree, 1902
Communion
Amish
We also confess and observe the breaking of bread, or Supper, as the Lord Christ Jesus before His suffering instituted it with bread and wine, and observed and ate with His apostles, commanding them to observe it in remembrance of Him;
Quaker (Friends)
We interpret the words and actions of Jesus near the end of his life as an invitation to recall and re-enact the self-giving nature of God’s love at every meal and every meeting with others, and to allow our own lives to be broken open and poured out for the life of the world.
From Quaker faith & practice (Britain Yearly Meeting) 27.41, London Yearly Meeting, 1986
Sacraments
Amish
neither baptism, supper, church [membership], nor any other outward ceremony, can without faith, regeneration, change or renewing of life, avail anything to please God or to obtain of Him any consolation or promise of salvation;
Quaker (Friends)
However valid and vital outward sacraments are for others, they are not, in our experience, necessary for the operation of God’s grace. We believe we hold this witness in trust for the whole church.
From Quaker faith & practice (Britain Yearly Meeting) 27.38, London Yearly Meeting, 1986
Leadership
Amish
No central organization or national church authority holds the subgroups together. Most districts in an affiliation have similar practices, but even so the ultimate authority for Amish life and practice lies in the local district.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Organization
Quaker (Friends)
The area meeting is the primary meeting for church affairs in Britain Yearly Meeting. Its role is to develop and maintain a community of Friends, a family of local meetings who gather for worship and spiritual enrichment.
Who may be ordained
Amish
Ordained officials, literally called “servants” in the Pennsylvania German dialect, normally serve for life. None has formal theological training—living a consistent Amish way of life is their most important credential. Although they may receive occasional gifts of food, the leaders are not paid for their church work and must support themselves by other occupations.
From Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies, Amish Studies: Leadership
Quaker (Friends)
The priesthood of all believers is a foundation of our understanding of the church. Our own experience leads us to affirm that the church can be so ordered that the guidance of the Holy Spirit can be known and followed without the need for a separated clergy
From Quaker faith & practice (Britain Yearly Meeting) 27.35, London Yearly Meeting, 1986
Remarriage
Amish
Amish churches forbid their members to seek a divorce or to remarry while a husband or wife is still living, and a member who does either faces excommunication and shunning.
From Can the Amish Get Divorced? No, Their Church Forbids It
Quaker (Friends)
When they are called upon to conduct weddings for divorced persons, we ask our ministers to consider the circumstances carefully in conjunction with scriptural admonitions (Mark 10:11-12; Matthew 19:89; 1 Corinthians 7:39), and perhaps in consultation with the leaders of their congregations, before deciding whether to perform the ceremony.

Where each came from
The Amish are Anabaptists, from the radical wing of the Reformation in Switzerland. Anabaptists held that baptism belongs to adults who can choose it — which was a capital offence in the sixteenth century, and many were executed for it.
In 1693 Jakob Ammann, a Swiss minister, broke with the wider Mennonite community over discipline, principally whether members under the ban should be shunned in daily life as well as excluded from communion. He held that they should. Those who followed him became the Amish.
The Quakers begin a century and a half later and in another country. George Fox, dissatisfied with every church he could find, concluded in the early 1650s that God speaks directly to every person without the need of clergy, buildings or sacraments. The movement grew rapidly and was persecuted severely; thousands were imprisoned.
The name was originally an insult — a judge’s mockery of Fox telling him to tremble at the word of the Lord. They call themselves the Religious Society of Friends.
The two families did end up neighbours, and a Quaker is the reason. William Penn founded Pennsylvania in 1682 and promoted religious freedom there as his “holy experiment,” and the first Amish reached it in the 1730s, escaping persecution in Europe. In 1737 the Charming Nancy set sail with 21 Amish families aboard. Penn had died in 1718 and never saw them land, but the freedom he promised was still standing when they did.

The real difference
It is about where authority sits, and everything else follows from it.
The Amish locate authority in Scripture as read and applied by the gathered congregation, expressed in the Ordnung — the set of understandings each local church maintains about how to live. It is largely unwritten, decided by the members, and it differs from district to district. That is why Amish practice varies so much: there is no central body to standardise it.
This does not mean God has gone quiet for them. The Anabaptist family believes God still speaks, and it listens for him in Scripture. Mennonites, the cousins the Amish parted from in 1693, say in their 1995 confession, “We believe that God continues to speak through the living and written Word.” The Amish hold to the Dordrecht Confession, a Dutch Anabaptist statement of 1632 that is older than the Amish themselves by sixty-one years, and every candidate for baptism reviews its articles.
Quakers locate authority in the inward light: the conviction that God addresses each person directly. Traditional Quaker worship is silence, and anyone may speak if they believe they have been given something to say. There is no creed, and no sacraments, on the grounds that the outward sign is unnecessary where the reality is present.
We ought to be fair to Friends here, because they have never thrown the Bible away. Robert Barclay in 1678 called it “a secondary rule, subordinate to the Spirit,” and he claimed the Scriptures’ own word for that: “so they testify that the Spirit is that Guide by which the saints are led into all truth: therefore, according to the Scriptures the Spirit is the first and principal Leader.” Three centuries later British Friends were telling each other the same thing: “The same Spirit which inspired the writers of the Bible is the Spirit which gives us understanding of it: it is this which is important to us rather than the literal words of scripture.”
These are not variations on a theme. They are different answers to the question of how God is known.
Not every Friend would give that answer. Evangelical Friends Church International says of the 66 books of the Bible “that there can be no appeal from these Scriptures to any other authority whatsoever.” The one word Quaker covers both, so when we ask what Quakers believe about the Bible we have to ask which Quakers we mean.

How does each hope to be saved?
Ask either of them how a person is saved and the two sound least alike. Amish leaders do not press the assurance of salvation. They speak instead of a “living hope,” which the scholars at the Young Center at Elizabethtown College describe as “an abiding belief that God will grant faithful followers eternal life.” Peter blessed God for just such a hope, “a lively hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead” (1 Peter 1:3). The Amish hold it humbly, trusting that salvation flows from obedient living in the community of faith, and the word they use for that whole posture is Gelassenheit, yielding oneself to God and to others.
That is why baptism weighs so much among them. Most Amish take the vow between 18 and 22, and it is a vow for life. A member who breaks it and will not repent may be excommunicated and shunned, and the cost is real. The practice varies from place to place and talking need not stop, but members may not take rides or goods from the one who is shunned or sit with them at meals, and “Expulsion from the church can lead to a lifetime of estrangement from family and friends.” The door still stays open: “those who do fall from grace can always return to the fold if they are willing to confess their wrongs and mend their ways.” Those who leave before baptism face no discipline at all.
Friends begin somewhere else, with whether we have met the Light. William Penn wrote in 1694, “The Light of Christ within, who is the Light of the world and so a light to you that tells you the truth of your condition, leads all that take heed unto it out of darkness into God’s marvellous light; for light grows upon the obedient.” And the Quaker hope is for holiness in this life, here and now. “The Light leads to holiness,” says Britain Yearly Meeting’s book of discipline, Quaker faith & practice, and George Fox said how far he believed it goes: “So as man and woman come again to God, and are renewed up into his image, righteousness and holiness by Christ, thereby they come up into the Paradise of God, the state which man was in before he fell, and into a higher state than that, to sit down in Christ that never fell.” Penn’s last word is obedience, and the Amish would say the same. They part over what we may say of ourselves while we are still on the road.

What happens when they gather?
An Amish congregation has no church building. Every other Sunday the district meets at one member’s home, in the house or in a basement, a barn or a large shop, with no altar, candles, organ, choir or pulpit. They sing slowly in German without instruments, the old tunes carried in memory, and many of the words, printed in their hymnbook the Ausbund, were written by Anabaptist prisoners. A thirty-minute opening sermon is followed by a main sermon of an hour or more, preached without notes in Pennsylvania Dutch. Each autumn and spring they keep communion, an eight-hour service of preaching and bread and wine, in which pairs of members wash each other’s feet while the congregation sings. Ammann pressed for communion twice a year and for the washing of feet in 1693, and his people have kept both.
Why keep up an eight-hour service and the washing of feet? The Mennonite side of the family answered that in a confession of 1963: “The Lord Jesus and His apostles instituted ordinances for the church to observe permanently as symbols of Christian truths. The apostolic church literally observed them.” Jesus gave the church these acts to keep, so they keep them.
Friends ask their people to wait instead. William Penn gave the reason in 1693: “This world is a form; our bodies are forms; and no visible acts of devotion can be without forms. But yet the less form in religion the better, since God is a Spirit; for the more mental our worship, the more adequate to the nature of God; the more silent, the more suitable to the language of a Spirit.” The phrase is Jesus’ own, spoken at the well: “God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth” (John 4:24).
We said that Friends keep no sacraments, and we should let them say why. John Wilhelm Rowntree wrote in 1902, “It is the inward change, the inward purification, the spiritual fact and not the outward symbol, that belongs in truth to the Kingdom of God.” They say much the same about ministers. “The priesthood of all believers is a foundation of our understanding of the church. Our own experience leads us to affirm that the church can be so ordered that the guidance of the Holy Spirit can be known and followed without the need for a separated clergy,” London Yearly Meeting said in 1986, and that is why a traditional meeting has no pastor.

Can women preach?
Among the Amish, no. Among Friends, yes, and they have from the start.
An Amish congregation is ordered by obedience. “Members are taught to obey those with authority over them: children their parents, students their teachers, wives their husbands, members their leaders, and younger ministers their bishop,” the Young Center explains, and the bishop, the ministers and the deacon of each district are always men, chosen by lot from among men the members have nominated. Women share in the naming, and mothers, the Young Center says, “are very active in nurturing the spiritual life of children.”
For Friends the answer follows from the Light itself. “Women were to play a full part in the life of the church alongside men,” says Quaker faith & practice, and it sets beside that the words of Elizabeth Bathurst in 1683, “as male and female are made one in Christ Jesus, so women receive an office in the Truth as well as men.” She was hearing Paul: “there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians 3:28).

What they share
Three things, and they are substantial.
Refusal to fight. Both are historic peace churches. Both have suffered for it, and both have long records of alternative service in wartime.
Refusal to swear oaths. Both take literally do not swear an oath at all (Matthew 5:34), and both have won legal accommodations as a result.
Plainness. Both began with plain dress and plain speech as a rejection of social display. Quakers used thee and thou to everyone precisely because the polite form implied rank. The Amish kept plainness; the Quakers largely let it go during the nineteenth century.

What they do not share
Separation is the big one. The Amish practise withdrawal from wider society — limited technology, their own schools, minimal participation in public life — on the basis of do not conform to the pattern of this world (Romans 12:2) and do not be yoked together with unbelievers (2 Corinthians 6:14).
Quakers went the opposite way and became famously involved. They were early and sustained abolitionists, prominent in prison reform, mental health reform and relief work. The Friends Service Council and the American Friends Service Committee shared the Nobel Peace Prize in 1947 for relief work after the war.
The two refusals of war differ in the same way. The Amish take the Sermon on the Mount at its word: “But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil” (Matthew 5:39). In their eyes the kingdoms of this world, which use coercion, are a different thing from the peaceable kingdom of God, so they forbid self-defence as well as entering the armed forces.
Friends carried the same refusal out into the world’s quarrels. George Fox told the Commonwealth commissioners in 1651 that he “lived in the virtue of that life and power that took away the occasion of all wars,” and Friends have gone on trying to take that occasion away. In 1915, with the nations of Europe at war, London Yearly Meeting told its members, “It is not enough to be satisfied with a barren negative witness, a mere proclamation of non-resistance. We must search for a positive, vital, constructive message.”
We saw the Amish way at its costliest on October 2, 2006, when a gunman shot ten Amish schoolgirls at Nickel Mines, Pennsylvania, killing five of them before taking his own life. That same day, neighbours took food to his widow, and within hours Amish people had reached out to her and to his parents and forgiven him. Families who had just buried their own daughters went to his burial and hugged his widow, and money from the funds given for the victims went to his family. A father who lost a daughter that day said ten years later that he “made that immediate choice in principle,” and that “it took me a few years until I could feel that I really meant it inside me.” Jesus had said, “Love your enemies, bless them that curse you” (Matthew 5:44), and those families did it.
Two groups, both refusing to take up arms, one by withdrawing from the world and one by going further into it.

Frequently asked
Are Amish and Quakers the same?
No. The Amish are Swiss Anabaptists dating from 1693; Quakers are English and date from the 1650s. They differ on authority, worship, sacraments and engagement with society.
Do Quakers dress plainly?
Historically yes, but the practice was largely abandoned during the nineteenth century. Most Quakers today are not distinguishable by dress.
Do both refuse to fight?
Yes. Both are historic peace churches and both refuse oaths, on the basis of Matthew 5:34.
Why are the Amish separate from the world?
They apply Romans 12:2 and 2 Corinthians 6:14 to daily life through the Ordnung, the local set of understandings each district maintains.
Do Quakers have ministers?
Traditional unprogrammed meetings have none. Many Quaker churches in the United States are programmed and do have pastors.
What do Quakers believe about Mary?
Quakers have no creed and no teaching about Mary of their own, though Friends who keep the historic statements confess with George Fox that Christ “was conceived by the Holy Ghost, and born of the Virgin Mary.” Fox wrote those words to the Governor of Barbados in 1671, and Wilmington Yearly Meeting in Ohio still prints the letter in its Faith and Practice. Nor do Friends ask for her prayers: their Society was to have “but one Master and no intermediary affecting any individual’s relationship to God.” The Amish confess the same birth in the Dordrecht Confession of 1632, which says that Christ “was conceived in the virgin Mary,” and they say no more about her than the Gospels do.
Do the Amish vote?
They may, though few do unless a local issue is on the ballot. The Amish generally avoid holding public office and political activism, and they are taught to respect and pray for those who govern.
More from this seriesWho Are The Amish?See all 35 articles
Leave a Reply