No, not in itself. Catholic, Orthodox and many Protestant churches teach that a patient may stop a treatment whose burdens outweigh its benefits, and that doing so is not suicide. What they forbid is ending a life on purpose. The Bible does not mention dialysis, but it forbids murder (Exodus 20:13).
For a patient worn out by the machine, or a family keeping watch beside the bed, that line matters. Scripture knows there is “a time to be born, and a time to die” (Ecclesiastes 3:2). The churches set taking a life on one side and, on the other, no longer holding back a death that the illness is bringing. They ask that the choice be made honestly, by the patient where possible, with the doctors and the family close by.

What happens when someone stops dialysis?
Dialysis is a treatment that, in the words of the National Kidney Foundation, “helps your body remove extra fluid and waste products from your blood when the kidneys are not able to.” In hemodialysis a machine filters the blood, usually in sessions of about four hours three times a week; in peritoneal dialysis the lining of the abdomen serves as the filter. For a sudden kidney injury, dialysis may be needed only until the kidneys recover. For kidney failure, the foundation says, dialysis “is not a cure,” and the patient will need it “for the rest of your life or until you are able to get a kidney transplant.”
The foundation states that patients “have the right to make the decision to stop dialysis.” People who stop “may live anywhere from one week to several weeks, depending on the amount of kidney function they have left and their overall medical condition,” and “death from kidney failure is usually painless,” with medicine available for any discomfort. A patient who stops is usually eligible for hospice care, and “you may go back on dialysis if you change your mind.”

Is stopping dialysis the same as suicide?
Churches that forbid suicide distinguish the two by what the person intends and by what causes the death. The Catholic Catechism condemns “an act or omission which, of itself or by intention, causes death in order to eliminate suffering” (CCC 2277). It then says that “discontinuing medical procedures that are burdensome, dangerous, extraordinary, or disproportionate to the expected outcome can be legitimate; it is the refusal of ‘over-zealous’ treatment. Here one does not will to cause death; one’s inability to impede it is merely accepted” (CCC 2278).
Refusing a burdensome treatment, in the words of the Vatican’s 1980 Declaration on Euthanasia, “is not the equivalent of suicide; on the contrary, it should be considered as an acceptance of the human condition, or a wish to avoid the application of a medical procedure disproportionate to the results that can be expected, or a desire not to impose excessive expense on the family or the community.” The same line holds outside Rome. Abigail Rian Evans, a Presbyterian bioethicist, told the Pew Research Center in 2013 that forgoing treatment for a terminally ill patient differs from assisted suicide “because it is the illness, rather than the withdrawal of treatment, that is ending life.” And the National Kidney Foundation, answering the same question, says that “many religions teach that individuals have the right to stop treatment, including dialysis, if they feel it is not helping and is burdensome.”

Catholic teaching on burdensome treatment
The 1980 declaration recalls that moralists in the past held that “one is never obliged to use ‘extraordinary’ means,” a principle that “still holds good,” and notes that “some people prefer to speak of ‘proportionate’ and ‘disproportionate’ means.” It says the judgment is made by comparing the treatment’s complexity, risk and cost “with the result that can be expected, taking into account the state of the sick person and his or her physical and moral resources.” It adds that “when inevitable death is imminent in spite of the means used, it is permitted in conscience to take the decision to refuse forms of treatment that would only secure a precarious and burdensome prolongation of life, so long as the normal care due to the sick person in similar cases is not interrupted.”
The Catechism sets two limits. “Even if death is thought imminent, the ordinary care owed to a sick person cannot be legitimately interrupted.” And painkillers may be used “even at the risk of shortening their days” if death “is not willed as either an end or a means, but only foreseen and tolerated as inevitable.” It calls palliative care “a special form of disinterested charity” (CCC 2279).

What do Orthodox churches teach?
The Holy Synod of the Orthodox Church in America, in affirmations issued in 1992, called for “extreme care” to find “the ‘royal path’ between providing all necessary healing measures and merely prolonging the biological functioning of organs when human life is no longer possible, or even present.” A later OCA parish resource on medical ethics says the Church “cannot and does not support” euthanasia or assisted suicide, but that for a patient whose body has begun irreversible processes leading to death, “our Church is not against the removal of Artificial Life Support when it is agreed that the continuation will not lead to any demonstrable benefit and it is consistent with the patient’s desires.” It says the decision should be made after consultation with the patient’s physicians and “in counsel with one’s parish priest.”

What do Protestant churches teach?
Protestant churches have no single teaching. Several large denominations draw the same line between allowing death and causing it. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America’s 1992 message “End-of-Life Decisions” says that “the integrity of the life processes which God has created should be respected; both birth and death are part of these life processes,” and that respect for each person “includes giving due recognition to each person’s carefully considered preferences regarding treatment decisions.” Roger Willer, the ELCA’s director of theological ethics, told Pew in 2013: “Allowing something to happen is different than actively hastening death.”
The Southern Baptist Convention’s 1992 resolution on euthanasia rejects “any action which, of itself or by intention, causes a person’s death,” and opposes treating food and water as “extraordinary treatment.” A Southern Baptist ethicist quoted by Pew applied the principle to an older patient dying of kidney failure, unable to receive a transplant and reacting badly to dialysis: “Must that person continue dialysis despite its ravaging effects on their body? No, not in my view and not in the view of most Southern Baptists I know.”
According to Pew, the United Methodist Church opposes euthanasia but does not require the terminally ill to use every possible treatment, provided they do not intend to hasten death. The Seventh-day Adventist statement “Care for the Dying” (1992) says patients are not obligated “to accept medical interventions whose burdens outweigh the probable benefits.” A few churches go further: Pew reports that the United Church of Christ supports the right of terminally ill patients to decide when to die, including whether to hasten death.

What does the Bible say?
Scripture was written long before dialysis, and no passage addresses a decision to stop a treatment. It does set out principles that bear on the question. Human beings are made “in the image of God” (Genesis 1:27), and the commandment “You shall not murder” (Exodus 20:13) forbids taking innocent life. Scripture also accepts medical remedies. When King Hezekiah was “at the point of death,” he prayed and was promised fifteen more years, and the prophet Isaiah ordered a cake of figs laid on his boil “that he may recover” (2 Kings 20:1–7). James tells the sick to call the elders of the church to “pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord” (James 5:14).
Other passages speak about death itself. Ecclesiastes says there is “a time to be born, and a time to die” (Ecclesiastes 3:2). Paul, writing from prison (Philippians 1:13), said: “For to me to live is Christ, and to die is gain…. My desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better. But to remain in the flesh is more necessary on your account” (Philippians 1:21–24). He wrote to the Romans, “whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s” (Romans 14:8).

Who makes the decision?
The Catholic Catechism says the decision “should be made by the patient if he is competent and able or, if not, by those legally entitled to act for the patient, whose reasonable will and legitimate interests must always be respected” (CCC 2278). The 1980 declaration adds that account must be taken of “the reasonable wishes of the patient and the patient’s family, as also of the advice of the doctors who are specially competent in the matter.” The OCA resource names the physicians and the parish priest.
On the medical side, the National Kidney Foundation says the care team will want to understand the reasons for stopping, such as worsening health, specific treatment problems or depression, to see whether changes to treatment could help. If the team is concerned that the decision comes from depression, it may ask the patient to speak with a psychiatrist, social worker or other counseling professional; the foundation notes that “depression may be treated successfully with counseling, medicine or a combination of both.” It also suggests speaking with a religious adviser, and it says patients can name someone to make decisions for them if they become unable to. None of it has to be decided alone, and Paul’s words hold for the one who stops and for those who keep watch: “whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s” (Romans 14:8).


Leave a Reply