Comparación de denominaciones136 artículos

Vino de comunión o jugo de uva, pan leudado o sin levadura



  • Wine is the older practice at Communion: the Coptic Orthodox Church, the Church of England and the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod ask for wine and nothing else, the Catholic Church asks for wine or, by a bishop’s leave, unfermented must, and the Presbyterian Church in America furnishes the table with bread and wine.
  • Grape juice came in through the Methodists, after Thomas Welch, a Methodist dentist in Vineland, New Jersey, found a way in 1869 to keep it from fermenting.
  • The United Methodist Church may use grape juice, the Church of the Nazarene and the Seventh-day Adventists require it, the PC(USA) always offers a non-alcoholic cup beside any wine, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America lets a congregation put juice on the altar beside the wine.
  • Jehovah’s Witnesses use plain red wine and unleavened bread, and Latter-day Saints use bread and water.
  • Catholics of the Latin Church use unleavened bread and the Eastern Orthodox and Copts bake theirs with yeast, and in 1439 the Council of Florence accepted both.
  • The Church of England, the ELCA and the United Methodist Church allow either kind of bread, and the Gospels themselves leave open which kind Jesus broke.
  • The Catholic Church, the Missouri Synod and the United Methodist Church all make room for people who cannot drink wine or eat ordinary wheat bread, so it is worth a word with the pastor or priest before the service.
Comparación de denominacionesVer los 136 artículos en esta serie

Wine is the older practice at the Lord’s table. The Coptic Orthodox Church, the Church of England and the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod ask for wine and nothing else, the Catholic Church asks for wine or, by a bishop’s leave, unfermented must, and the Presbyterian Church in America sets a table “furnished with bread and wine.” Grape juice came in through the Methodists, after Thomas Welch, a Methodist dentist in Vineland, New Jersey, found a way in 1869 to keep it from fermenting. The United Methodist Church may still use it, the Church of the Nazarene and the Seventh-day Adventists require it, the PC(USA) always sets a non-alcoholic cup beside any wine, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America uses wine but lets a congregation put grape juice on the altar too. Jehovah’s Witnesses use plain red wine, and Latter-day Saints use water. With the bread the lines fall in other places: Catholics of the Latin Church receive unleavened wheat bread, Eastern Orthodox and Coptic Christians bake theirs with yeast, Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses use bread without leaven, and the Church of England, the ELCA and the United Methodist Church allow either kind.

All of us are reaching back to the same table. It was “the first day of the feast of unleavened bread” (Matthew 26:17) when Jesus took bread and broke it, and when he had passed the cup he said, “I will not drink henceforth of this fruit of the vine, until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father’s kingdom” (Matthew 26:29). He spoke of the cup and of the fruit of the vine, and nearly every argument over what we drink at his table comes back to those words.

Iglesia Bread and cup En sus propias palabras
Católica (Iglesia latina) Unleavened wheat bread; grape wine with a little water; mustum by a bishop’s leave Wine “natural from the fruit of the vine”
Ortodoxa oriental Leavened bread “Leavened bread has always been used in the Eastern Church”
Ortodoxa copta Leavened bread; fermented wine mixed with water “Uses yeast to leaven the bread”
Luterana (Sínodo de Misuri) Bread and wine only; low-alcohol wine allowed “Only bread and wine should be used”
Lutheran (ELCA) Leavened or unleavened bread; wine, with juice allowed on the altar “The bread may be leavened or unleavened”
Anglicana (Iglesia de Inglaterra) Leavened or unleavened wheat bread; fermented wine “The fermented juice of the grape”
Presbyterian (PCA) Pan y vino “Furnished with bread and wine”
Presbiteriana (PC(USA)) Everyday bread; wine if the session chooses, juice always offered “A non-alcoholic option shall be provided”
Iglesia Unida de Cristo One loaf and one cup; some churches offer juice “Non-alcoholic and gluten-free elements”
Metodista Unida Either kind of bread; grape juice allowed “May continue to use grape juice”
Iglesia del Nazareno Grape juice only “Only unfermented wine”
Los adventistas del séptimo día Unleavened bread; grape juice “Only unfermented grape juice and unleavened bread”
Iglesias de Cristo Bread; grape juice Apologetics Press: “the cup of grape juice”
Discípulos de Cristo A loaf; juice or wine “Little cups of juice or wine”
Baptist, Pentecostal, Oneness Pentecostal Bread and the cup; the kind is not named Baptist Faith and Message: “the fruit of the vine”
Menonita y Amish Bread and cup; Dordrecht tells what Christ used and sets no rule Dordrecht Confession: “with bread and wine”
No denominacional No shared statement; each church decides No shared statement
testigos de Jehová Unleavened bread; plain red wine “Not grape juice”
Santos de los Últimos Días Pan y agua “Bread and water”
Quakers, Salvation Army No outward bread and cup Salvation Army: “not to observe specific sacraments”

Nuestra herramienta gratuita, Comparar denominaciones cristianas, sets any two of 23 churches side by side on the bread and the cup and on 54 other questions.

We could not find the Wisconsin Synod’s or the Episcopal Church’s own rule, so the Lutheran and Anglican rows above speak only for the bodies they name.

Did Jesus use wine or grape juice at the Last Supper?

The supper was a Passover, kept on “the day of unleavened bread, when the passover must be killed” (Luke 22:7), so the question is what a Passover cup held, and the churches answer it from the same few lines. Justin Martyr, explaining the Christians’ worship to the emperor Antoninus Pius, says that at the Eucharist “There is then brought to the president of the brethren bread and a cup of wine mixed with water,” and Paul had to scold the Corinthians because at their Supper “one is hungry, and another is drunken” (1 Corinthians 11:21). So the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod can say in a line, “The elements referred to in Scripture are without question bread and wine,” and Jehovah’s Witnesses say that Jesus used “unleavened bread and red wine that were left over from the Passover meal.”

Seventh-day Adventists read the same night through the Passover law, which told Israel, “Seven days shall ye eat unleavened bread; even the first day ye shall put away leaven out of your houses” (Exodus 12:15). Their Church Manual quotes Ellen White, “The Passover wine, untouched by fermentation, is on the table,” and reasons that “Neither the wine nor the bread contained elements of fermentation.” The Assemblies of God notices that Jesus did not use the usual Greek word for wine, and in a position paper of 2016 it says that “the phrase ‘fruit of the vine’ is consistent with the prohibition against yeast or fermentation during the Passover week.”

How did grape juice come into Communion?

It came out of American Methodism in the 1800s, when the temperance movement was asking people to give up drink altogether. In 1864 the General Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church recommended that “the pure juice of the grape be used in the celebration of the Lord’s Supper.” Raw juice, as UMC.org puts it, “naturally ferments into wine,” and the same history says, “Most churches, however, simply continued to use wine.” Four years later Thomas Welch, a former Wesleyan Methodist preacher whose throat had sent him into dentistry, became communion steward of the Methodist Episcopal church in Vineland, New Jersey. “In 1869, he perfected a juice pasteurization process in his kitchen and began selling ‘Dr. Welch’s Unfermented Wine’ to churches preferring an alcohol-free substitute for Communion.”

Welch gave the business up after four years, and his son Charles took it up again and handed out free samples. In 1880 the Methodist Episcopal Church ruled, “Let none but the pure, unfermented juice of the grape be used in administering the Lord’s Supper, whenever practicable.” In 1916, Christian History magazine reports, Methodists made grape juice mandatory, “and soon after many other Protestants did also.” Charles wrote in his will why it had begun: “Unfermented grape juice was born in 1869 out of a passion to serve God by helping His Church to give its communion ‘the fruit of the vine.’”

The United Methodist Church still tells the story, and says that “Today, United Methodists still commend, but do not require, abstinence, and may continue to use grape juice in communion out of pastoral concern for people who may have problems with alcohol.” The Church of the Nazarene makes juice the rule, and its Manual of 2023 says, “Only unfermented wine should be used in the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper.” Whether a Christian may drink at all is a wider question, which we take up in ¿es pecado beber alcohol?

Which churches use only wine?

The Catholic Church’s Code of Canon Law says that “The wine must be natural from the fruit of the vine and not spoiled,” with “a little water” mixed in (canon 924), so the Church’s law keeps the Lord’s own phrase, and a Vatican letter of 2017 adds, “Nor are other drinks of any kind to be admitted for any reason.” The only grape juice it allows is mustum, kept from fermenting, and then only by a bishop’s leave. Catholics believe this wine becomes the blood of Christ, as we explain in what transubstantiation means. The Coptic Orthodox Church uses wine “comprised of fermented grapes” and mixes water into it too, because, its Diocese of the Southern United States says, “The mixing of wine and water is symbolic of Christ’s side that gushed out blood and water when speared upon the cross” (John 19:34). Cyprian of Carthage taught the same mixing in the third century: “water alone cannot be offered, even as wine alone cannot be offered.”

The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod asked its congregations in 2001 and again in 2023 to use only wine, and its theology commission’s report of December 2025 commends “the Synod’s long-standing teaching that only bread and wine should be used in the Lord’s Supper,” because “the use of an element other than wine is an alien practice in the churches of the Augsburg Confession and brings about doubt whether the Sacrament is offered or not.” It is gentle with the congregations that serve juice, saying they do it “to aid members who suffer from alcoholism or others who are on medications that should not be taken together with alcohol,” and it commends “the compassion and pastoral concern that these practices represent.”

Three more churches write wine into their own rules, each in its own way. The Church of England’s Canon B 17 asks for “the wine the fermented juice of the grape, good and wholesome.” The Presbyterian Church in America’s Book of Church Order pictures the minister at a table “decently covered, and furnished with bread and wine” (58-5). Jehovah’s Witnesses name the wine more exactly than anyone: “We use bread without leaven or added ingredients and plain red wine, not grape juice or wine that has been sweetened, fortified, or spiced,” says jw.org.

Which churches use grape juice?

Beside the United Methodists and the Nazarenes stand the Seventh-day Adventists, whose Church Manual says that “only unfermented grape juice and unleavened bread are appropriate for use in the communion service.” The Churches of Christ have no central body to set a rule, but Apologetics Press, a teaching ministry among them, describes the Supper as they keep it: “When Christians eat that small piece of bread and drink the cup of grape juice, we should remember that we do so for a very important reason.”

Which churches offer both wine and juice?

Several churches keep wine at the table and make room for juice beside it, or leave the choice to each congregation, so that nobody has to go without the cup. The Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) hands the choice to the session and says so in its Book of Order: “The session will determine whether wine is used; a non-alcoholic option shall be provided and clearly identified.” The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America says in Principle 44 of its 1997 statement The Use of the Means of Grace that “this church uses bread and wine in the celebration of the Lord’s Supper,” and adds that “In certain circumstances, congregations might decide to place small amounts of non-wheat bread or non-alcoholic wine or grape juice on the altar.” The United Church of Christ says that “Some churches provide non-alcoholic and gluten-free elements.” The Disciples of Christ, in a report to their General Assembly in 1991, speak of “little cups of juice or wine” without choosing between them.

Which churches set no rule on the cup?

Many confessions keep Jesus’ own words, “the fruit of the vine” or simply “the cup,” and go no further, so they leave wine or juice to the congregation. The Baptist Faith and Message, the confession of the Southern Baptist Convention, calls the Supper “a symbolic act of obedience whereby members of the church, through partaking of the bread and the fruit of the vine, memorialize the death of the Redeemer and anticipate His second coming.” The Assemblies of God’s Statement of Fundamental Truths speaks of “the elements—bread and the fruit of the vine,” though the fellowship has “a century-old tradition of abstinence from alcohol.” The United Pentecostal Church International, a Oneness Pentecostal body, teaches in its Articles of Faith that Christ instituted “the use of literal bread and the fruit of the vine.”

The confessions of the Amish and of Mennonite Church USA speak the same way. The Dordrecht Confession of 1632, which the Amish hold to, tells what Christ did, that he “instituted it with bread and wine,” and sets no rule for the cup today. Mennonite Church USA’s Confession of Faith says that “the cup is a sign of the new covenant in his blood,” without saying what fills it. Nondenominational and evangelical churches have no shared statement on the cup, so each congregation decides for itself.

Why do Catholics use unleavened bread and the Orthodox leavened bread?

With the bread, the question goes back to a puzzle in the Gospels. Matthew, Mark and Luke set the supper on “the first day of unleavened bread, when they killed the passover” (Mark 14:12). John sets it “before the feast of the passover” (John 13:1), and the next morning those who had brought Jesus to Pilate still kept out of the judgment hall “that they might eat the passover” (John 18:28). So the old Catholic Encyclopedia says plainly that “It is a debated question whether Christ used leavened or unleavened bread,” and the Missouri Synod’s report says that “The earliest evidence indicates that ordinary table bread was used.”

The Orthodox Church in America says that “leavened bread has always been used in the Eastern Church,” while “in the Christian West unleavened bread was the norm,” and the difference became one of the quarrels of the years when Rome and Constantinople broke apart. In 1053 Leo, metropolitan of Ochrid in Bulgaria, wrote a letter complaining of Latin customs, “especially fasting on Saturday and the use of azyme (unleavened) bread for the Holy Eucharist,” and on 16 July 1054 the pope’s envoys laid their bull of excommunication on the altar of Hagia Sophia, a story we tell in how the Orthodox and Catholic churches differ and why they split. When bishops of East and West met at Florence, their decree of 6 July 1439 said that “the body of Christ is truly confected in both unleavened and leavened wheat bread,” each priest following “the custom of his western or eastern church.”

The Code of Canon Law gives the Catholic reason as tradition: “According to the ancient tradition of the Latin Church, the priest is to use unleavened bread in the eucharistic celebration whenever he offers it” (canon 926). The Orthodox Church in America explains that “In the Christian East there is no concern for using the exact type of bread used at the Last Supper,” because “Christ ‘leavens’ our lives, so to speak.” The Copts find the gospel in the dough itself, and their diocese says that “Yeast is symbolic of sin (i.e., hypocrisy–the yeast of the Pharisees),” and that “Baking in a hot oven kills the yeast, symbolic of Christ abolishing sins in His holy body.” Only deacons and clergy may make those round loaves, and all 150 Psalms are prayed while they are made, in a bakery the Copts call “Bethlehem,” the House of Bread.

Does Communion bread have to be unleavened?

Seventh-day Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses both use bread without leaven, because to both of them leaven speaks of sin, and the Adventist Church Manual quotes Ellen White’s words for fermentation, “the symbol of sin and death.” Jehovah’s Witnesses point to Paul’s words, “Purge out therefore the old leaven, that ye may be a new lump, as ye are unleavened. For even Christ our passover is sacrificed for us” (1 Corinthians 5:7), and jw.org concludes, “Thus, only bread free from leaven and other additives can be a fitting symbol for Christ’s sinless body.”

Other Christians answer that leaven in Scripture is not always a picture of sin, for Jesus also said, “The kingdom of heaven is like unto leaven, which a woman took, and hid in three measures of meal, till the whole was leavened” (Matthew 13:33). The Baptist Bulletin, the magazine of the General Association of Regular Baptist Churches, notes that “Nowhere in the New Testament are we specifically commanded to use unleavened bread,” and it quotes Charles Spurgeon: “Where there is no ordinance, there is no obligation; and we are, therefore, left free to use the bread which it is our custom to eat.”

Some churches simply allow either kind. The Church of England asks for bread “whether leavened or unleavened,” and the ELCA says, “The bread may be leavened or unleavened.” The United Methodist Church gives each kind its own meaning: “Either leavened (in witness to the resurrection) or unleavened (in witness to the cleansing power of the Holy Spirit) may be used.” The PC(USA) asks only for bread “common to the culture of the congregation,” much as the Second Helvetic Confession of 1566, one of the confessions in its Book of Confessions, had spoken of “bread and wine, taken from things commonly used for meat and drink.” The Book of Order adds that “The use of one loaf and one cup expresses the unity of the body of Christ,” and Paul had written long before, “For we being many are one bread, and one body: for we are all partakers of that one bread” (1 Corinthians 10:17).

Why do Latter-day Saints use water?

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints uses bread and water, and it traces the water to August 1830, when, as the heading in its Doctrine and Covenants tells it, Joseph Smith “set out to procure wine” for a service and “was met by a heavenly messenger.” The revelation says, “it mattereth not what ye shall eat or what ye shall drink when ye partake of the sacrament, if it so be that ye do it with an eye single to my glory” (Doctrine and Covenants 27:2), and the heading adds, “Water is now used instead of wine in the sacramental services of the Church.” For Latter-day Saints, “The water is a reminder that the Savior shed His blood” in His suffering, from Gethsemane to the cross.

What if I cannot drink wine or eat wheat?

If you are in recovery from alcohol, or you live with celiac disease, you are far from the first to come to the Lord’s table with this, and many churches have made room for you, so it is worth a quiet word with your pastor or priest before the service. Catholics may receive “under the form of bread alone” (canon 925), and a bishop may allow “Low-gluten hosts” or “Mustum, which is grape juice,” though “Hosts that are completely gluten-free are invalid matter.” The Missouri Synod allows “low or non-alcoholic wines” and “low-gluten wheat hosts.” United Methodist congregations “are expected to provide alternatives for persons with celiac disease and other allergies,” and they remind anyone who can take only the bread or only the cup that this “does not alter the benefits of the sacrament.”

Which churches have no bread and cup at all?

Quakers and the Salvation Army keep no outward Supper. The Salvation Army’s Handbook of Doctrine says that “Early in our history, The Salvation Army was led of God not to observe specific sacraments, that is baptism and the Lord’s Supper, or Holy Communion, as prescribed rituals.” British Quakers hold in Quaker faith & practice that worship “not necessarily including the words and actions usually recognised as eucharistic, may equally serve as a channel for this power and grace.” How the churches came to count two sacraments, or seven, or none, is told in how many sacraments there are.

Wine or juice or water, a wafer or a loaf risen with yeast, Paul tells every one of us what we are doing when we come: “For as often as ye eat this bread, and drink this cup, ye do shew the Lord’s death till he come” (1 Corinthians 11:26).


Más de esta serieComparación de denominacionesVer todos los 136 artículos



Respuestas

Deja una respuesta

Share to...