Biblical Debates: Are Christmas Trees Linked to Pagan Traditions?

What are the pagan origins of the Christmas tree tradition?

In the Roman world, evergreen boughs were used to decorate temples during the festival of Saturnalia in late December. The Egyptians brought green palm branches into their homes on the winter solstice as a symbol of life’s triumph over death. In Northern Europe, the pre-Christian peoples revered evergreen plants, seeing in their enduring greenery a promise that life would return in the spring (Kahveci, 2012, pp. 8–14; Kozhukhar, 2022).

Among Germanic tribes, there was a tradition of decorating an evergreen tree as part of worship of Odin during the midwinter festival of Yule. This “Yule tree” was often hung with sacrificial offerings to the gods. Some scholars see in this custom a precursor to our modern Christmas tree (Fajfrić, 2014, pp. 251–266; Perry, 2020).

But we must be cautious about drawing too direct a line between these ancient practices and our Christian tradition. The development of customs is complex, with meanings and symbolism evolving over time. What began as a pagan rite can be transformed and sanctified when embraced by the Christian faithful.

, the Christmas tree as we know it today emerged much later, in 16th century Germany. It was there that devout Christians began bringing decorated trees into their homes. German Lutherans are often credited with being the first to add lighted candles to the tree, a practice said to have been inspired by Martin Luther’s awe at the starry winter sky (Kahveci, 2012, pp. 8–14; Roach, 2012, p. 99).

So Although we can trace some elements of the Christmas tree to pre-Christian traditions, its development as a specifically Christian symbol came much later. Let us see in this history not a cause for concern a reminder of how our faith can transform and redeem cultural practices, infusing them with new, Christ-centered meaning. This fusion of faith and culture highlights the adaptability and universality of the Christian message, reminding us that God’s truth can be woven into diverse customs and traditions. Just as the Christmas tree has been imbued with new significance, the origin of Christmas Eve itself points to a rich history of preparation, reflection, and joyful anticipation of Christ’s birth. Through these symbols and celebrations, we are invited to experience the transformative power of faith in our everyday lives.

How did the Christmas tree become incorporated into Christian celebrations?

The journey of the Christmas tree into the heart of Christian celebration is a fascinating tale of cultural exchange and spiritual adaptation. I am moved by how this symbol evolved to express the joy of Christ’s birth. Its origins can be traced back to ancient pagan traditions that celebrated evergreen trees as symbols of life and renewal during the winter solstice. Over time, these practices were woven into Christian traditions, transforming the use of evergreens into a meaningful representation of eternal life and hope. The history of the Christmas tree is a testament to how diverse cultural practices can converge to create enduring, shared symbols of faith and festivity. The history of the Christmas tree reminds us of humanity’s ability to infuse old customs with new meaning, creating rituals that resonate across generations. Today, decorating a Christmas tree is a cherished tradition for many families, symbolizing unity, remembrance, and the light of Christ. As we gather around its illuminated branches, we are part of a legacy that bridges ancient heritage with modern spirituality.

The pivotal moment came in 16th century Germany, where Protestant reformers, particularly in Lutheran areas, began to encourage the practice of setting up Christmas trees in homes. This was part of a broader shift to emphasize Christmas as a child-centered celebration rather than primarily a church feast (Kahveci, 2012, pp. 8–14; Roach, 2012, p. 99).

A key figure in popularizing the Christmas tree was Prince Albert, the German husband of Queen Victoria. When the royal family embraced this tradition in the 1840s, it sparked a trend that spread rapidly through England and then to the United States. An 1848 illustration of the royal family gathered around their Christmas tree created a sensation, inspiring many to adopt this custom (Kosciejew, 2021, pp. 457–475).

But we must note that the acceptance of Christmas trees was not universal or immediate among Christians. In fact, for a long time, the Christmas tree was considered a Protestant tradition, sometimes called a “Luther tree.” Many Catholics were initially wary of this custom. As late as 1909, some Benedictine monks referred to the Christmas tree tradition as a “fraud” (Roach, 2012, p. 99).

Yet, over time, the beauty and symbolism of the Christmas tree touched the hearts of Christians across denominations. People found in it a powerful visual representation of Christian themes – evergreen as a symbol of eternal life, lights representing Christ as the Light of the World, the star atop reminding us of the Star of Bethlehem (Swank, 2013, p. 129).

The Christmas tree also became a focal point for charity and community spirit. In many places, public Christmas trees became gathering spots for carol singing and gift-giving to the less fortunate. This aligned well with the Christian emphasis on generosity and community during the Christmas season (Cole, 2012).

What does the Bible say about Christmas trees?

But there are passages that some have interpreted as relevant to this tradition, both positively and negatively. Let us examine these with care, always seeking to understand the deeper spiritual truths they convey.

One passage often cited in discussions of Christmas trees is Jeremiah 10:1-5. In these verses, the prophet speaks against the customs of the nations, describing the cutting down of a tree, decorating it with silver and gold, and fastening it with hammer and nails so it will not totter. Some have seen in this a condemnation of Christmas tree-like practices (Hamon, 2019). However, a closer examination of the context reveals that these Bible verses about Christmas trees may not explicitly refer to holiday traditions but rather critique idolatry. The passage describes the crafting and worship of idols, rather than festive decorations. Thus, while some interpret it as a warning against Christmas trees, others argue that it addresses entirely different practices (Smith, 2021).

But we must be cautious in applying this passage to our modern custom. The context of Jeremiah’s words is a warning against idolatry, specifically the creation of wooden idols. The Christmas tree, as used by faithful Christians, is not an object of worship but a symbol of celebration.

On a more positive note, many find echoes of Christmas tree symbolism in biblical imagery of trees. In Revelation 22:2, we read of the tree of life bearing fruit and leaves for the healing of the nations. This evokes the evergreen nature of Christmas trees and their association with life amidst winter (Mindaugas & KondratienÄ—, 2023, pp. 73–79).

The Bible also uses tree imagery in ways that resonate with Christmas themes. Isaiah 11:1 speaks of a shoot coming from the stump of Jesse, a messianic prophecy that some connect to the Christmas tree. In Luke 13:18-19, Jesus compares the Kingdom of God to a mustard seed that grows into a great tree where birds can nest, an image of growth and shelter that some see reflected in the Christmas tree (McCaughrean & Willey, 2003).

The Bible often uses trees as symbols of life, growth, and God’s blessing. From the trees in the Garden of Eden to the cedars of Lebanon praised for their majesty, trees hold a special place in biblical imagery (Hooke, 2024, pp. 119–127).

What is the Christian symbolism and meaning behind Christmas trees?

The evergreen nature of the tree has come to symbolize the eternal life offered to us through Christ. In the midst of winter, when other trees have lost their leaves, the evergreen reminds us of the enduring nature of God’s love and the promise of resurrection (Hooke, 2024, pp. 119–127; Swank, 2013, p. 129).

The lights adorning the tree evoke Christ as the Light of the World, a theme deeply rooted in Scripture. As Jesus proclaimed, “I am the light of the world. Whoever follows me will never walk in darkness but will have the light of life” (John 8:12). The twinkling lights on the tree can remind us of Christ’s light shining in the darkness of our world (Swank, 2013, p. 129).

The star often placed atop the tree recalls the Star of Bethlehem that guided the Magi to the Christ child. This can serve as a powerful reminder of how God guides us to encounter Christ in our lives (Swank, 2013, p. 129).

Some Christians see in the triangular shape of the tree a symbol of the Holy Trinity – Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Others are reminded of the cross, as some traditions speak of the wood of the manger prefiguring the wood of the cross (McCaughrean & Willey, 2003).

The custom of bringing the tree into our homes and decorating it can be seen as a reflection of how we are called to welcome Christ into our hearts and adorn our lives with virtues. Just as we carefully decorate each branch, we are invited to allow Christ to transform every aspect of our being (Roach, 2012, p. 99).

In some traditions, the Christmas tree is associated with the Jesse Tree, a visual representation of Jesus’ genealogy based on Isaiah 11:1. This connection emphasizes Christ’s human lineage and the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies (McCaughrean & Willey, 2003).

The practice of giving gifts placed under the tree can remind us of the gifts brought by the Magi, and more profoundly, of God’s gift of His Son to the world. It encourages us to cultivate a spirit of generosity in imitation of God’s abundant love (Cole, 2012).

Did early Church Fathers write anything about Christmas trees or similar traditions?

But the Church Fathers did address themes and practices that bear some relation to elements we associate with the Christmas tree tradition. Their reflections can provide us with valuable insights into how early Christians approached cultural customs and symbols. For instance, they often emphasized reinterpreting and sanctifying existing cultural symbols to reflect Christian theology, a practice that laid the groundwork for later innovations in holiday observances. This approach helps illuminate how certain symbols, like evergreens, became integrated into the celebration of Christ’s birth as expressions of eternal life and hope. In examining these developments, we can see how Catholic Christmas traditions explained deeper theological truths through the adaptation of pre-Christian customs, bridging the sacred and the familiar. This fusion of the sacred and the familiar allowed early Christians to communicate profound theological concepts in ways that resonated with the cultural contexts of their time. Sacred Christmas symbols and meanings, such as the evergreen tree representing eternal life, exemplify this harmonization of faith and tradition. By reclaiming and redefining these symbols, the Church illuminated the transformative message of Christ’s Incarnation, inviting believers to see divine truth reflected in everyday elements of their world. This blending of the sacred and the familiar highlights the Church’s ability to engage with diverse cultures while conveying the core message of the Gospel. By imbuing pre-Christian symbols with new meaning, the early Christians created traditions that resonated both spiritually and culturally, making the faith more accessible to converts. In exploring how Catholic Christmas traditions explained the profound truths of salvation through such adaptations, we gain a deeper appreciation for the rich tapestry of symbolism woven into the celebration of Christ’s birth.

One relevant area of patristic thought is the Christian reinterpretation of pagan customs. Many Church Fathers, while strongly opposing idolatry, also recognized that certain cultural practices could be “baptized” and given new, Christian meanings. For instance, St. Gregory of Nazianzus, in his Oration 39 for the Epiphany, speaks of Christ as the “new light” that supersedes pagan light festivals (Chistyakova & Chistyakov, 2023).

The use of evergreen plants in Christian worship was addressed by some early writers. Tertullian, in his treatise “On the Crown,” criticized the use of laurel wreaths as having pagan associations. But he also acknowledged that plants created by God were not inherently problematic – it was their use in idolatrous practices that he opposed (Freitas, 2022, pp. 519–534).

The symbolism of trees and light, both important elements in the Christmas tree tradition, feature prominently in patristic writings. St. Irenaeus, in his work “Against Heresies,” develops a rich theology of the “tree of life,” connecting it to the cross of Christ. This theological motif, while not directly related to Christmas trees, shows how early Christian thinkers found deep spiritual meaning in tree imagery (Chistyakova & Chistyakov, 2023).

St. John Chrysostom, in his homilies on the Gospel of Matthew, reflects on the star that guided the Magi, emphasizing how God uses created things to lead people to Christ. While not about Christmas trees specifically, this idea resonates with how Christians later came to see the star atop the tree as a symbol of divine guidance (Freitas, 2022, pp. 519–534).

Many Church Fathers were cautious about introducing new customs into Christian worship, preferring to focus on the essentials of faith. St. Augustine, for instance, warned against the proliferation of human traditions that might obscure the simplicity of the Gospel message.

May we, like the early Church Fathers, always seek to interpret the cultural symbols around us in light of the Gospel, finding in them opportunities to deepen our faith and share the joy of Christ’s coming with others.

Are Christmas trees considered idolatrous by some Christians? Why or why not?

The question of whether Christmas trees are considered idolatrous by some Christians is a complex one, rooted in both historical context and personal faith. I must approach this matter with both pastoral sensitivity and historical understanding. While Christmas trees are widely embraced as a symbol of the holiday season, their origins and associations with pre-Christian practices have led some believers to question their place in Christian worship. For these individuals, navigating the intersection of Bible mysteries and Christmas traditions often involves discerning whether certain customs align with Scripture or potentially detract from its core message. Ultimately, this decision varies among Christians, influenced by their theological perspectives and the meanings they ascribe to such practices. For others, however, Christmas trees are seen as a neutral cultural tradition, one that can be imbued with Christian significance or simply enjoyed as a festive decoration. Interestingly, conversations about atheists and Christmas traditions also highlight how such customs transcend religious boundaries, serving as unifying symbols of togetherness and celebration. Thus, the interpretation and acceptance of Christmas trees within Christian practice often reflect a broader interplay between faith, culture, and individual conscience. For others, the Christmas tree is seen as a neutral or even positive cultural expression, devoid of any idolatrous connotations, and used simply as a festive decoration to honor the season of Christ’s birth. This divergence in opinion also ties into the larger debate of is celebrating Christmas a sin, as some view certain Christmas customs as potentially compromising their commitment to biblical principles, while others embrace these traditions with the intent of glorifying God. Respecting these diverse convictions requires an ongoing dialogue rooted in grace and a shared commitment to understanding Scripture. For many Christians, the meaning of xmas in Christianity centers around the celebration of the Incarnation and the hope it brings to the world. This awareness invites believers to explore how customs like decorating a Christmas tree can be tools for enriching their faith, rather than detracting from it. Ultimately, each individual’s understanding of these traditions contributes to a richer tapestry of religious expression during the holiday season.

It is true that some Christians have expressed concerns about Christmas trees, viewing them as potentially idolatrous. This perspective often stems from a desire to remain faithful to God’s commandments, particularly the prohibition against idolatry found in Exodus 20:4-5. These believers worry that decorating and venerating a tree might constitute worship of a created thing rather than the Creator.

But we must also consider the intentions and hearts of those who incorporate Christmas trees into their celebrations. For most Christians, the Christmas tree is not an object of worship rather a symbol of joy, life, and the light of Christ coming into the world. It serves as a focal point for family gatherings and a reminder of God’s gift of His Son.

Historically we see that the use of evergreen branches as decoration during winter festivals predates Christianity. Some argue this pagan origin makes Christmas trees incompatible with Christian faith. Yet, as a we have often found ways to redeem cultural practices, infusing them with new, Christ-centered meaning.

Psychologically, symbols like the Christmas tree can serve important functions in our faith journey. They can evoke memories, create a sense of continuity with our past, and provide tangible ways to express abstract spiritual concepts. For many, the Christmas tree becomes a way to physically manifest the joy and anticipation of Christ’s birth.

Whether a Christmas tree is considered idolatrous depends largely on the heart and intent of the individual. If it becomes a distraction from the true meaning of Christmas or an object of worship itself, then it becomes problematic. But if it serves to enhance one’s celebration of Christ’s birth and draw one’s heart toward God, it can be a beautiful expression of faith.

I encourage each of you to prayerfully consider your own use of Christmas trees. Let us remember that our God looks not at outward appearances at the heart. May all our Christmas celebrations, with or without trees, be centered on the miraculous gift of the Incarnation and the hope it brings to all humanity.

How can Christians reconcile using Christmas trees with their faith?

The question of reconciling the use of Christmas trees with our Christian faith is one that requires thoughtful reflection, historical understanding, and a deep commitment to the core of our beliefs. As we journey together in faith, let us approach this matter with open hearts and minds, seeking to understand God’s will for our lives and our celebrations.

We must remember that our faith is not based on symbols or traditions on the saving grace of Jesus Christ. The Apostle Paul reminds us in Colossians 2:16-17, “Therefore do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a New Moon celebration or a Sabbath day. These are a shadow of the things that were to come; the reality is found in Christ.” This passage encourages us to focus on the substance of our faith rather than becoming overly concerned with outward forms.

Historically, we see that the Church has often adapted and transformed cultural practices, imbuing them with new, Christ-centered meanings. The Christmas tree, with its evergreen branches pointing heavenward, can be seen as a symbol of eternal life in Christ. The lights adorning the tree can remind us of Jesus as the Light of the World (John 8:12). In this way, what was once a pagan symbol has been redeemed for the glory of God.

Psychologically, symbols like the Christmas tree can serve as powerful reminders of our faith, helping to create a sacred space within our homes during the Advent and Christmas seasons. They can become focal points for family devotions and opportunities to teach children about the birth of Christ and the hope He brings to the world. These cherished traditions remind us of the deeper meaning of the season, extending beyond the material elements of holiday celebrations. With symbols of Christmas explained to younger generations, such as the star atop the tree representing the Star of Bethlehem, families can pass down the rich spiritual heritage of the holiday. In doing so, these symbols gain even greater significance, fostering love, unity, and a shared sense of purpose centered on the joy of Christ’s coming. These sacred symbols of Christmas not only deepen our sense of connection to the divine but also foster a spirit of gratitude and reflection during this holy season. By surrounding ourselves with these meaningful representations, we are invited to pause and center our hearts on the true essence of Christmas amidst the busyness of modern life. In this way, these symbols enrich our celebrations and remind us of the enduring message of love and redemption.

But reconciliation also requires honest self-examination. We must ask ourselves: Does the Christmas tree enhance our worship of Christ, or does it distract from it? Does it serve as a tool for evangelism, allowing us to share the Gospel story with others, or has it become merely a cultural tradition devoid of spiritual significance?

As Christians, we are called to be in the world but not of it (John 17:14-15). This means engaging with our culture while maintaining our distinct identity in Christ. The use of Christmas trees can be an example of this principle in action – participating in a widespread cultural practice while infusing it with deep spiritual meaning.

The key to reconciling Christmas trees with our faith lies in our hearts and intentions. If we use them as a means to celebrate and proclaim the birth of our Savior, they can be a beautiful expression of our faith. But we must always be vigilant, ensuring that no tradition or symbol ever takes the place of Christ in our hearts and worship.

What are some Bible verses that relate to the symbolism of Christmas trees?

We might consider the evergreen nature of the Christmas tree, which can symbolize eternal life in Christ. This reminds us of Jesus’ words in John 3:16: “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life.” The enduring green of the tree, even in the depths of winter, can serve as a powerful reminder of the everlasting life we have in Christ.

The lights that adorn the Christmas tree can be connected to Jesus’ declaration in John 8:12: “I am the light of the world. Whoever follows me will never walk in darkness will have the light of life.” As we gaze upon the twinkling lights of the tree, let them remind us of Christ’s light shining in the darkness of our world, guiding us and offering hope.

The star often placed atop the Christmas tree recalls the star that led the Wise Men to the infant Jesus. Matthew 2:9-10 tells us: “After they had heard the king, they went on their way, and the star they had seen when it rose went ahead of them until it stopped over the place where the child was. When they saw the star, they were overjoyed.” May the star on our trees remind us to seek Christ with the same dedication and joy as the Magi.

In Isaiah 55:13, we read a prophecy that can be beautifully connected to the Christmas tree: “Instead of the thornbush will grow the juniper, and instead of briers the myrtle will grow. This will be for the Lord’s renown, for an everlasting sign, that will endure forever.” This verse speaks of transformation and renewal, which is at the heart of the Christmas message.

The practice of bringing greenery into our homes can also be related to Nehemiah 8:15: “Go out into the hill country and bring back branches from olive and wild olive trees, and from myrtles, palms and shade trees, to make temporary shelters.” While this verse refers to the Feast of Tabernacles, it illustrates the use of branches in celebration and remembrance of God’s provision.

Lastly, as we decorate our trees with ornaments, we might reflect on 1 Peter 3:3-4: “Your beauty should not come from outward adornment, such as elaborate hairstyles and the wearing of gold jewelry or fine clothes. Rather, it should be that of your inner self, the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is of great worth in God’s sight.” This passage reminds us that while outward decorations can be beautiful, it is the state of our hearts that truly matters to God.

How did Martin Luther influence the tradition of Christmas trees?

Martin Luther, the great reformer of the 16th century, is often credited with popularizing the use of Christmas trees among Protestant Christians. Although the historical accuracy of this attribution is debated among scholars, the story associated with Luther captures a powerful spiritual truth that resonates with many believers.

According to tradition, on a cold winter’s night around the year 1500, Luther was walking through a forest, contemplating a sermon he was to deliver. As he looked up at the stars twinkling through the evergreen branches, he was struck by the beauty of the scene. In that moment, he is said to have experienced a powerful sense of God’s presence and the wonder of creation.

Moved by this experience, Luther reportedly brought a small evergreen tree into his home and decorated it with candles to recreate the scene for his family. He wanted to share with them the sense of awe and wonder he had felt, seeing it as a way to teach about Christ, the Light of the World, coming into the darkness of human existence.

Although we cannot verify the historical accuracy of this account, it reflects a deep truth about the human experience of faith. I see in this story a beautiful example of how sensory experiences can evoke spiritual insights and become powerful teaching tools. Luther, if the story is true, was engaging in what we might now call experiential learning, using a tangible symbol to convey abstract spiritual truths.

Historically, we know that the use of evergreen branches in winter celebrations predates Christianity. But Luther’s alleged innovation was to bring the entire tree indoors and to explicitly connect it with the celebration of Christ’s birth. This represents a fascinating example of the way Christian faith has often engaged with and transformed cultural practices.

Whether or not Luther himself introduced the Christmas tree tradition, we know that it became popular in Germany in the centuries following the Reformation. As Lutheranism spread, so did the practice of decorating Christmas trees. By the 19th century, the tradition had spread throughout much of Europe and North America, largely through the influence of German immigrants and the popularity of Prince Albert (Queen Victoria’s German husband) in England.

The story of Luther and the Christmas tree reminds us of the power of symbols to convey spiritual truths. It encourages us to look for God’s presence in the beauty of creation and to find creative ways to share our faith with others. At the same time, it cautions us to hold our traditions lightly, remembering that they are meant to point us toward Christ, not to become objects of veneration themselves.

What are some ways to make Christmas trees more meaningful for Christian families?

Consider making the decoration of the tree a time for sharing faith stories. As each ornament is hung, share a memory of God’s faithfulness in your lives or retell a story from Scripture. This practice not only creates precious family memories but also weaves the narrative of your faith into the very fabric of your Christmas celebrations.

Incorporate Scripture into your tree decorations. Create ornaments that feature Bible verses, particularly those that speak of Christ’s birth and its significance. As you place these on the tree, read the verses aloud, allowing God’s Word to fill your home and hearts.

Use the lights on your tree as a prompt for prayer. Each time you turn on the tree lights, remember Jesus as the Light of the World (John 8:12). Take a moment to pray that His light would shine through your family to others in your community.

Consider adding symbols of Christian faith to your tree. A cross ornament can remind us of the ultimate purpose of Christ’s coming – His sacrificial death for our salvation. A star atop the tree can recall the star that guided the Wise Men, prompting us to seek Christ in our daily lives.

Make your tree a focal point for advent devotions. Place your advent wreath near the tree, or hang advent-themed ornaments that can be used as part of daily or weekly family devotions leading up to Christmas.

Use your tree as an opportunity for generosity and outreach. Hang gift cards or notes on the tree representing donations made to charities in honor of Christ’s birth. Or create a “Jesse Tree” that tells the story of Jesus’ lineage, helping children understand the long history of God’s plan for salvation.

As a family, choose a “theme” for your tree each year that reflects an aspect of Christ’s character or a Christian virtue you want to focus on. This could be “The Fruit of the Spirit,” “The Names of Jesus,” or “God’s Promises,” with decorations chosen to reflect the theme.

Finally, remember that the tree itself – cut down, brought into our homes, and then discarded – can be a powerful metaphor for Christ’s humility in the Incarnation. Reflect on Philippians 2:5-8 as you set up and take down your tree, considering Christ’s willingness to leave His heavenly home for our sake.

Let us approach our Christmas trees not as mere tradition as opportunities for deepening our faith and sharing the love of Christ with others. May these practices help transform your Christmas tree into a true celebration of Emmanuel – God with us. As you gather around your tree this season, may you be filled with the wonder of God’s love and the joy of Christ’s birth.

—