Christmas as a Christian36 articles

Are Christmas Trees Pagan? No Record Ties Them to a Pagan Rite



  • The records show no pagan rite behind the Christmas tree, and the trees we can date with confidence stood in Christian towns of the German-speaking lands from the 1500s on.
  • Romans did hang laurels and greenery on their houses at the New Year, 1 January, and bishops were still forbidding it in the sixth century, but that older custom is a separate one.
  • Clement Miles thought in 1912 that the tree might descend from Roman greenery or older folk tree customs, yet he found no record joining them and wrote that its ancestry was “difficult to be certain” of.
  • The religious Christmas plays sometimes showed the tree of Paradise, at Oberufer a juniper hung with apples and ribbons, where Christians hung apples on a green tree at Christmas and called it the tree of Paradise.
  • Bede names the English Yule months and “mother’s night” on 25 December but describes no tree, and the story of a Yule tree hung for Odin rests on no ancient or medieval text we could find.
  • A Christian may keep a Christmas tree with a clear conscience, as Paul let the Christians of Corinth eat meat from the market without asking where it came from (1 Corinthians 10:25).
Christmas as a ChristianSee all 36 articles in this series

The Christmas tree has no pagan rite behind it that the records can show. Romans hung laurel and green branches at the New Year long before, a custom of its own, and the trees we can date with confidence stood in Christian towns of the German-speaking lands from the 1500s.

The fir in the forest belongs to God, whoever else has used it. “The earth is the Lord’s, and the fulness thereof,” says the psalm (Psalm 24:1), and Paul quoted it to Christians in Corinth who worried about meat that might have been offered to idols (1 Corinthians 10:26). Long before anyone set a fir tree in a parlour, Scripture had made the green tree a picture of the believer. The one who trusts in the Lord, Jeremiah says, “shall be as a tree planted by the waters, and that spreadeth out her roots by the river, and shall not see when heat cometh, but her leaf shall be green” (Jeremiah 17:8). Even Tertullian, who scolded Christians for hanging pagan laurels on their doors, turned to the believer and said, “You are a light of the world, and a tree ever green.”

Why do people say the Christmas tree is pagan?

The charge starts from something true: the Roman New Year fell on the Kalends of January, the first day of the month, and people decked their houses with laurel and greenery for it. Clement Miles, in his 1912 study of Christmas customs, found the practice “common throughout the Empire,” as Libanius, Tertullian and John Chrysostom describe it. The Church went on asking Christians to stop for a very long time. Miles reports that in the sixth century the rules of Bishop Martin of Braga still “forbid the adorning of houses with laurels and green trees,” and the green, Miles adds, found its way even into the churches in spite of them.

Tertullian’s own words are painful for Christians to read. In his treatise On Idolatry he lists the Saturnalia, New Year’s and the midwinter festivals among the pagan days believers were keeping, with “presents” that “come and go.” Then he turns to the lamps and laurels hung on doors at public rejoicings for emperors and victories: “You will now-a-days find more doors of heathens without lamps and laurel-wreaths than of Christians.” Some Christians of his day were doing what their neighbours did. Tertullian forbade it outright, because the Romans had gods of doors and thresholds: “To an idol you will have done whatever you shall have done to an entrance.”

People often name the Saturnalia first, yet it is the weakest part of the case. The Roman writer Macrobius gives it three days from 17 December under Augustus, or seven with the market of little clay figures that followed, and the sources fill those days with feasting, gifts of candles and clay figures, and masters waiting on their slaves at table. It was a feast of food, gifts and households turned upside down, and in none of the sources does a tree appear. Miles himself judged the Saturnalia’s influence on Christmas “less certain” than that of the Kalends. The wider case about the Saturnalia, the sun and the date of the feast is weighed in does Christmas have pagan origins?

Did the Christmas tree come from older folk customs?

This is the question behind the whole worry: is the tree in our front room an old sacred tree in disguise? Miles gave the strongest case for it that we know of, and it is more interesting than the usual one. He took up an earlier scholar’s idea, Dr Tille’s, that two things met in the tree: the Roman custom of decking houses “with laurels and green trees at the Kalends of January,” and the old belief that on Christmas Eve apple and other trees blossomed and bore fruit. A link with the Roman New Year was, to him, “very possible.” Yet he saw closer likenesses in village customs that “in no way suggest Roman or Greek influence,” such as the little fir set over a village fountain in Alsace on New Year’s Eve. He put the Christmas tree in “a class of primitive sacraments” with the May-pole, and thought it “may well be a descendant of some sacred tree carried about or set up at the beginning-of-winter festival.”

Miles, though, never claimed to have found the line from one to the other, and said so: “it is difficult to be certain of their exact ancestry.” We can take his case seriously and still notice what it is. It is a family likeness between customs, drawn by a careful scholar who could not find the records that would join them. If someone tells us our tree is an old sacred tree in disguise, this is the best evidence that can be called, and the man who gathered it called it uncertain.

In the same chapter Miles set down the Christian side as well: the religious Christmas plays sometimes showed the people “the tree of Paradise,” at Oberufer a juniper hung with apples and ribbons, and that story belongs to the history and meaning of the Christmas tree. A family likeness to the May-pole has to be weighed beside a likeness to Eden, and the second has the plays on its side, where Christians at Christmas hung apples on a green tree and called it the tree of Paradise.

What do the earliest records of the Christmas tree show?

The records show no pagan rite, and Miles himself wrote that “there is no recorded instance of the use of a tree at Christmas in Germany before the seventeenth century.” Research since his day has turned up older traces, gathered by Bernd Brunner in his book Inventing the Christmas Tree, the oldest claimed at Freiburg in 1419, though another scholar finds firm evidence there only from 1625. Some of these early trees belonged to the whole winter season rather than to Christmas: Strasbourg banned the cutting of branches for the New Year in 1494, and one account of Riga’s tree of 1510 says it was set up for the winter solstice, though Riga’s own mayor admitted in 2015 that no one knows when the city’s first tree was decorated. Whatever day each one marked, the people who set them up lived in the Christian towns of northern Europe.

By 1605 a citizen of Strasbourg was writing about firs set up in the parlours of his city and hung with paper flowers, fruit and sweets, and a few decades later the cathedral preacher there, who disliked the custom, admitted that he did not know where it came from. If a pagan rite had stood behind it, the preacher nearest to it could not name one.

Between the Roman laurels and these town records, the sources Miles and Brunner gathered show no tree at all. That silence proves nothing either way. It leaves the pagan link unproven, and the tree we can see in the records is the one Christian households kept.

Did Norse or Germanic pagans have a Yule tree?

The English of old kept something on the night of 25 December, and the Venerable Bede tells us what he knew of it. In his book on the reckoning of time he says they named two months Giuli “from the day when the sun turns back” and began their year on 25 December. “That very night, which we hold so sacred,” he writes, “they used to call by the heathen word Modranecht, that is, ‘mother’s night’, because (we suspect) of the ceremonies they enacted all that night.” Notice the little word “suspect”. Bede could only guess at those ceremonies, and he names no tree.

The Germanic peoples did honour trees, and the oldest life of Boniface tells how he felled a great oak that pagans held sacred, and Willibald, who wrote it, says some of the people there, “not yet strong in the spirit,” still offered “sacrifices to trees and springs.” But Willibald says nothing of decorating the oak, or of midwinter. The often-repeated story that Germanic tribes hung a Yule tree with offerings to Odin rests on no ancient or medieval text that we have been able to find.

Does Jeremiah 10 say Christmas trees are pagan?

Jeremiah 10 is about an idol, a god made by hand that his people were afraid of, and a winter custom first written down in the 1500s was nowhere in his sight. The passage is read verse by verse in is the Christmas tree in the Bible?

Can a Christian have a Christmas tree?

A Christian can, and Paul answered a harder question than this one in Corinth. Some of the meat sold in the market there had been offered to idols, and believers asked whether they could eat it. “Whatsoever is sold in the shambles, that eat, asking no question for conscience sake” (1 Corinthians 10:25), and his reason is the psalm we began with: the earth is the Lord’s. Only if someone at the table says “this is offered in sacrifice unto idols” should they leave it, for that person’s conscience (verses 28–29). Over all of it Paul writes: “whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God” (verse 31).

Our own case is easier than theirs, because the meat in Corinth had at least been near an altar, and the fir in our front room has never been near one. It grew on the Lord’s earth and was cut for the birth of his Son. And if a guest at our table is troubled by it, Paul has already shown us the way: we think of the guest before we think of the tree.

Tertullian began his chapter on lamps and laurels with a word of Jesus: “let your works shine.” In his day, he complained, the shops and gates shone instead. A tree can glitter in a house where no one prays; it can also stand where a family prays by its light. When we light ours this December, we stand on the Lord’s earth beside one of his trees, and we ask for the brightness he wants most: “Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven” (Matthew 5:16).


More from this seriesChristmas as a ChristianSee all 36 articles



Responses

Leave a Reply

Share to...