Forgiveness vs Reconciliation: Forgiving Is Not Going Back



  • Forgiveness lets go of what someone owes you for a wrong, and Jesus asks it of us without limit.
  • Reconciliation restores the relationship, and it needs both people, including real repentance from the one who did the harm.
  • David spared King Saul twice and left the judgment to God, but when Saul said “return”, David went on his way and did not go back.
  • Forgiving someone does not mean forgetting, trusting them again before they have changed, or staying where you are not safe.
  • The Catholic bishops of the United States teach that no one is expected to stay in an abusive marriage, and the Southern Baptist Convention urges abuse victims to separate from their abusers and contact the authorities.
  • If you are in danger in the United States, the National Domestic Violence Hotline answers day and night at 1-800-799-7233.

Forgiveness and reconciliation are two different things. Forgiving means letting go of what someone owes you for the wrong they did, and Jesus asks it of us without limit. Reconciliation means the relationship is restored, and that takes two people: the one who did the wrong has to turn from it. You can forgive someone and still stay away.

If someone is hurting you now, or you are being told that forgiving means going back to a person who is not safe, hear this first: forgiveness does not ask you to return to danger. In the United States the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential and open day and night at 1-800-799-7233 (800-799-SAFE), or text START to 88788. If you are in danger right now, call your local emergency number. The Catholic bishops of the United States say it without hedging: “no person is expected to stay in an abusive marriage.”

Scripture shows us what this looks like in the life of a man who was wronged for years. King Saul hunted David to kill him, and twice David had Saul at his mercy and let him live. The first time, David called after the king, “mine hand shall not be upon thee,” and Saul wept: “Thou art more righteous than I: for thou hast rewarded me good, whereas I have rewarded thee evil” (1 Samuel 24:12, 17). It sounds like repentance. Then comes one quiet sentence: “And Saul went home; but David and his men gat them up unto the hold” (24:22). David did not go home with him.

The second time, Saul went further. “I have sinned: return, my son David: for I will no more do thee harm” (1 Samuel 26:21). David sent back the king’s spear and still did not return: “So David went on his way, and Saul returned to his place” (26:25). He refused to take revenge on a man who wanted him dead, and left the judgment to God, as he had told Saul at their first meeting: “The LORD judge between me and thee” (24:12). And he would not put himself back within reach of that spear.

What is the difference between forgiveness and reconciliation?

Jesus explains forgiveness with a debt. A servant owes his king ten thousand talents, more than he could ever pay, and the king “was moved with compassion, and loosed him, and forgave him the debt” (Matthew 18:27). The debt was real. The king did not pretend otherwise. He chose not to collect it. That is what we do when we forgive: we name the wrong as a wrong, and we stop demanding that the other person pay for it.

Forgiveness can happen in one heart, even alone. “When ye stand praying, forgive, if ye have ought against any,” Jesus says (Mark 11:25). The other person does not need to be in the room. From the cross he prayed for the men who were killing him, “Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do” (Luke 23:34), and none of them had asked.

Reconciliation needs both people. “If thou bring thy gift to the altar, and there rememberest that thy brother hath ought against thee; Leave there thy gift before the altar, and go thy way; first be reconciled to thy brother” (Matthew 5:23–24). Paul knew it could not always happen. “If it be possible, as much as lieth in you, live peaceably with all men” (Romans 12:18). Two limits in one verse: if it is possible, and as far as it depends on you. Only half of a reconciliation is ever ours to give.

Can you forgive someone who has not repented?

Scripture asks two things here, and both are true. Jesus tells us to forgive whenever we pray, as in Mark 11:25. He also says, “If thy brother trespass against thee, rebuke him; and if he repent, forgive him” (Luke 17:3), and in Matthew 18:15–17 he sets out how to go to someone who has sinned against you, first alone and then with others, hoping that “thou hast gained thy brother.”

Christians read these passages together in two ways. Some teach that forgiveness itself waits for repentance, as God’s forgiveness does, while we offer it freely and give up revenge in the meantime. Tim Staples of Catholic Answers puts it this way: forgiveness “is not unconditional. It’s a two-way street,” and “it cannot actually take place until there are willing partners on both sides of the divide.” Others teach that we forgive now, before any apology comes. Asked whether we should forgive someone who has not repented, Joel Kim, president of Westminster Seminary California, answered on Ligonier Ministries’ podcast, “The short answer is yes,” because “we’re forgiven people.”

Either way, Scripture leaves revenge to God, “Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord” (Romans 12:19), and a restored relationship still waits for the other person to turn (Luke 17:3). Until then, we can pray for them, refuse revenge, and keep our distance.

Letting go is rarely one decision. The Catechism of the Catholic Church is honest about how it feels: “It is not in our power not to feel or to forget an offense; but the heart that offers itself to the Holy Spirit turns injury into compassion and purifies the memory in transforming the hurt into intercession” (2843). Forgiving may mean praying, many times over, for someone we still cannot bear to see. There is more on that long road in how to forgive someone who keeps hurting you.

Does forgiving someone mean trusting them again?

No. Forgiveness is given. Trust is rebuilt, slowly, by the person who broke it. Joseph shows us this. When his brothers, who had sold him into slavery, came to Egypt for grain, he did not reveal himself at once. He tested them first, “that your words may be proved, whether there be any truth in you” (Genesis 42:16). He watched Judah, the brother who had once said “let us sell him” (Genesis 37:27), offer to become a slave himself so that Benjamin could go home: “let thy servant abide instead of the lad a bondman to my lord” (Genesis 44:33). Joseph had already wept twice, out of their sight (Genesis 42:24; 43:30). He felt it long before he trusted them. Only now did he weep before them and say, “I am Joseph your brother, whom ye sold into Egypt” (Genesis 45:4). He had seen that they were different men.

The Catholic bishops of the United States, writing on domestic violence in 2002, spell out what forgiveness does not mean. Abusers sometimes “cite Scripture to insist that their victims forgive them,” they write. “Forgiveness, however, does not mean forgetting the abuse or pretending that it did not happen. Neither is possible. Forgiveness is not permission to repeat the abuse.”

So forgiving someone does not mean:

  • forgetting what happened, or telling yourself it was not so bad;
  • trusting them again before they have shown they can be trusted;
  • going back to live with them, or seeing them alone;
  • keeping a crime from the police or the courts.

Jesus told his disciples to be “wise as serpents, and harmless as doves” (Matthew 10:16), and Proverbs says, “A prudent man foreseeth the evil, and hideth himself” (Proverbs 22:3). Jesus himself walked away when a crowd tried to throw him off a cliff: “he passing through the midst of them went his way” (Luke 4:30). Paul let himself be lowered over the wall of Damascus in a basket when his life was threatened (Acts 9:25). Leaving danger is not a failure of love.

What if I am told to reconcile with someone who abused me?

Sometimes the pressure comes from people we trust: a pastor, a parent, a friend who quotes “seventy times seven”. They may mean well. But two churches that teach marriage is for life, the Catholic Church and the Southern Baptist Convention, do not ask anyone to stay in harm’s way. The Catholic Church holds that a valid marriage between the baptized “cannot be dissolved by any human power or for any reason other than death” (Catechism, 2382). Southern Baptists define marriage as “covenant commitment for a lifetime”. Both say plainly that an abused spouse may separate.

The Catholic Church’s Code of Canon Law says that a spouse who “causes grave mental or physical danger to the other spouse or to the offspring” gives the other “a legitimate cause for leaving” (canon 1153), and the Catechism says that “the separation of spouses while maintaining the marriage bond can be legitimate in certain cases provided for by canon law” (2383). The US bishops add that “acting to end the abuse does not violate the marriage promises.” The Southern Baptist Convention, in a 2018 resolution, urged abuse victims “to contact civil authorities, separate from their abusers, and seek protection,” and called on churches “to pursue church discipline against impenitent abusers.”

Forgiveness sits in your heart before God. Reconciliation, if it ever comes, must be safe, and it waits on real change in the person who did the harm. If you are not sure whether what is happening to you is abuse, how to know if you’re in an abusive relationship may help you see it clearly.

What does reconciliation take?

When it is possible, reconciliation asks something of the one who did wrong. Zacchaeus did not stop at saying sorry. “If I have taken any thing from any man by false accusation, I restore him fourfold” (Luke 19:8). Repentance that is real shows itself in what a person does next, and keeps showing itself over time.

It also takes time. Paul and Barnabas quarrelled over John Mark, who had left them in Pamphylia on an earlier journey (Acts 13:13), “and the contention was so sharp between them, that they departed asunder one from the other” (Acts 15:39). Years later, writing from prison near the end of his life, Paul asks for him by name: “Take Mark, and bring him with thee: for he is profitable to me for the ministry” (2 Timothy 4:11). The Bible does not say how Paul and Mark made peace. It only shows us that they did.

What do the churches teach about forgiveness and reconciliation?

Christians of every tradition pray the Lord’s Prayer, “And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors” (Matthew 6:12), and their churches draw the same line from it: the forgiven forgive.

Catholics receive God’s forgiveness and are reconciled with the Church in the sacrament of Penance and Reconciliation, because sin “damages communion with the Church” as well as with God (Catechism, 1440). On forgiving others, the Catechism warns that God’s mercy “cannot penetrate our hearts as long as we have not forgiven those who have trespassed against us” (2840), and quotes St Cyprian: “God does not accept the sacrifice of a sower of disunion, but commands that he depart from the altar so that he may first be reconciled with his brother” (2845).

Lutherans learn from Luther’s Small Catechism that in the fifth petition we ask God to grant us everything “by grace”, and promise in turn to “heartily forgive and also readily do good to those who sin against us.”

Orthodox Christians begin Lent with Forgiveness Sunday. After vespers that evening, the faithful ask forgiveness of one another. Father Alexander Schmemann, in a meditation the Orthodox Church in America publishes for the day, calls it “the rite of forgiveness and reconciliation”, and writes that “Christianity itself is, above all, the religion of forgiveness.”

Brothers and sisters, if you have been hurt and are still hurting, you have not failed because you cannot yet feel at peace, or because you have chosen to stay safe. Forgiveness may take years. Reconciliation may never be possible in this life, and that is not yours to carry alone. God knows how deep the wound is, and he is not far from it: “The LORD is nigh unto them that are of a broken heart; and saveth such as be of a contrite spirit” (Psalm 34:18).





Responses

Leave a Reply

Share to...