Comparaison des dénominations135 articles

What Is Purgatory? Which Churches Believe in It



  • Purgatory is the Catholic teaching that some who die in God’s grace are cleansed after death before they enter heaven, and the Catechism says they are already “assured of their eternal salvation.”
  • Of the 23 churches we compare, only the Catholic Church teaches it, and Catholics help the dead with prayer, the Mass, alms and indulgences.
  • Eastern Orthodox and Coptic Orthodox Christians pray for their dead too, asking God for mercy and rest for them, but both churches reject purgatory.
  • No Protestant church we compare teaches purgatory, and the Lutheran, Anglican, Methodist and Westminster confessions reject it by name, though the Episcopal Church still prays that the souls of the departed may rest in peace.
  • Seventh-day Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that the dead are unconscious until the resurrection, and Latter-day Saints teach a spirit world of paradise and spirit prison.
  • The churches argue over the same passages, above all 2 Maccabees 12, Matthew 12:32 and Paul’s words about being saved “yet so as by fire” in 1 Corinthians 3.
  • Christians prayed for their dead long before the word purgatory, and Augustine’s mother Monica asked only to be remembered “at the Lord’s altar.”
Comparaison des dénominationsVoir les 135 articles dans ce série

Purgatory is the Catholic name for a cleansing that some of the saved pass through after they die, before they come into heaven. The Catechism of the Catholic Church says it in one sentence: “All who die in God’s grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven” (paragraph 1030). So everyone in purgatory, as Catholics understand it, is already on the way home. Of the 23 churches we compare, the Catholic Church is the only one that teaches it. The Eastern Orthodox and the Coptic Orthodox pray for their dead and still reject purgatory, no Protestant church we compare teaches it, Seventh-day Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that the dead know nothing until the resurrection, and Latter-day Saints teach a spirit world of their own.

Underneath the word is a much older question. When Augustine’s mother Monica lay dying at Ostia, his brother wished she might die in her own country, and she told her two sons not to trouble about it: “Lay this body anywhere, let not the care for it trouble you at all. This only I ask, that you will remember me at the Lord’s altar, wherever you be.” Can we still do anything for the people we love once they have died?

Église Purgatory? En ses propres termes
La vie dévotionnelle Yes, a final cleansing of the saved “After death they undergo purification”
Orthodoxe orientale No; prays for the dead “Does not accept the teaching on purgatory”
Orthodoxe copte No; prays for the departed “Reject the concept of purgatory”
luthériennes Non Smalcald Articles: “Nothing but a specter of the devil”
Anglican et épiscopal No; Episcopalians pray for the departed Church of England: “A fond thing vainly invented”
Méthodiste Non “Grounded upon no warrant of Scripture”
Presbytérien et réformé No; heaven or hell at death Westminster Confession: “The Scripture acknowledgeth none”
Baptiste (Confession de 1689) No; the righteous go to Christ “Received into paradise, where they are with Christ”
Armée du Salut Non “No substantial biblical foundation”
Églises du Christ Non “Prevents the acceptance of the doctrine of purgatory”
Mennonite (1963 Confession) No; the righteous go to Christ at once “Enter at once into conscious joy”
Pentecôtiste (Assemblées de Dieu) No statement on purgatory; no repentance after death “No possibility of repentance after death”
Nazarene, Oneness Pentecostal, Amish, Quaker No statement on purgatory; every soul is judged Nazarene Articles: “Every person shall appear before God”
Disciples du Christ No statement on purgatory A study paper: “Sin will not have the last word”
Non confessionnel No statement on purgatory Cape Town Commitment: “No longer face condemnation”
Église unie du Christ No statement on purgatory; remembers its dead Totenfest, to “remember and celebrate the lives of faithful people”
Les adventistes du septième jour No; the dead are unconscious “An unconscious state for all people”
Témoins de Jéhovah No; the dead are unconscious “The Bible does not contain the word”
Saints des derniers jours No purgatory; a spirit world Spirits who accept the gospel “may leave spirit prison”

Notre outil gratuit, Comparer les dénominations chrétiennes, sets any two of 23 churches side by side on purgatory and 54 other questions.

What does the Catholic Church teach about purgatory?

The Catechism calls purgatory “this final purification of the elect, which is entirely different from the punishment of the damned” (paragraph 1031), and it explains why someone already forgiven would still need it. Forgiveness takes away the guilt of sin, but “every sin, even venial, entails an unhealthy attachment to creatures, which must be purified either here on earth, or after death in the state called Purgatory” (paragraph 1472). What is cleansed, in other words, is the hold that lesser loves still have on a forgiven soul. We are not meant to picture God taking revenge, for the Catechism says the punishment of sin “must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without, but as following from the very nature of sin.”

Is there fire in purgatory? The Catechism says that “the tradition of the Church, by reference to certain texts of Scripture, speaks of a cleansing fire,” and it quotes Pope Gregory the Great: “As for certain lesser faults, we must believe that, before the Final Judgment, there is a purifying fire.” How long purgatory lasts and what it is like, the Catechism does not say, and the Council of Trent, in December 1563, told the bishops to keep “the more difficult and subtle questions” out of popular sermons. The decree is in our full text of the Council of Trent’s twenty-fifth session.

What Catholics are asked to do is help. Trent taught “that there is a Purgatory, and that the souls there detained are helped by the suffrages of the faithful,” and the Catechism says that “from the beginning the Church has honored the memory of the dead and offered prayers in suffrage for them, above all the Eucharistic sacrifice,” and that it “also commends almsgiving, indulgences, and works of penance undertaken on behalf of the dead” (paragraph 1032). An indulgence is “a remission before God of the temporal punishment due to sins whose guilt has already been forgiven,” and “indulgences may be applied to the living or the dead” (paragraph 1471). Limbo is another matter, and the two are set side by side in Limbes vs Purgatoire.

If someone you love has died and the word purgatory frightens you, it may help to hear how gently the Church itself speaks. The people Catholics pray for there are “indeed assured of their eternal salvation,” and the Catechism ends its lines on purgatory with St. John Chrysostom: “Let us help and commemorate them. If Job’s sons were purified by their father’s sacrifice, why would we doubt that our offerings for the dead bring them some consolation? Let us not hesitate to help those who have died and to offer our prayers for them.”

Is purgatory in the Bible?

The word is not. It comes from the Latin purgare, to make clean or to purify, and Jehovah’s Witnesses open their answer with that plain fact: “The Bible does not contain the word ‘purgatory,’ nor does it teach that the souls of those who have died are purified in purgatory.” Catholics say the teaching rests on “certain texts of Scripture” read with the Church’s tradition, and three passages come up again and again.

The first is a burial after a battle. When Judas Maccabeus and his men went to take up the bodies of the fallen, they found on them “some of the donaries of the idols of Jamnia, which the law forbiddeth to the Jews,” and Judas sent “twelve thousand drachms of silver to Jerusalem for sacrifice to be offered for the sins of the dead.” The chapter ends, “It is therefore a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead, that they may be loosed from sins” (2 Maccabees 12:40–46, Douay-Rheims). The Catechism hears in it the “practice of prayer for the dead, already mentioned in Sacred Scripture.” The Copts agree the passage is “a proof for the Resurrection and the belief in the prayer for the departed,” but they say it “does not mention anything related to the purgatory.” The Church of England’s Thirty-Nine Articles put the Second Book of Maccabees among the books the Church reads “for example of life and instruction of manners,” and say it does not “apply them to establish any doctrine.”

The second is Jesus’ warning about whoever speaks against the Holy Ghost: “it shall not be forgiven him, neither in this world, neither in the world to come” (Matthew 12:32). Gregory the Great reasoned from it, “From this sentence we understand that certain offenses can be forgiven in this age, but certain others in the age to come.” The Copts answer that “‘age to come’ refers to a time not a place,” and that the forgiveness meant is for someone who repented but died before he could confess, “for forgiveness and suffering do not go together.”

The third is Paul on the builders whose work “shall be revealed by fire”: “If any man’s work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire” (1 Corinthians 3:15). Augustine first read that fire as the grief we feel in this life when we lose the earthly things we loved too much, and then allowed that “it is not impossible that something of the same kind may take place even after this life.” The Copts answer in one line: “The fire is for the work not for the servant.”

The churches that reject purgatory turn to the promise Jesus made to the thief on the cross, “Today shalt thou be with me in paradise” (Luke 23:43), and to Paul’s longing “to depart, and to be with Christ; which is far better” (Philippians 1:23), and the 1689 Baptist Confession cites both. How soon a believer is with Christ is a question of its own, taken up in do believers go to heaven immediately when they die.

Where did the belief in purgatory come from?

Christians were praying for their dead long before anyone spoke of purgatory. Tertullian, listing customs the church kept by tradition where “no passage of Scripture has prescribed it,” says simply, “As often as the anniversary comes round, we make offerings for the dead as birthday honours.” Monica’s request belongs to that world, and her son kept it, asking the readers of his Confessions to “at Your altar remember Monica, Your handmaid.” What such prayers do, Augustine left open. “It is a matter that may be inquired into, and either ascertained or left doubtful,” he wrote in his Enchiridion, “whether some believers shall pass through a kind of purgatorial fire.”

The Western church settled it in council. At Florence, where Greek bishops sat with the Latins, the decree of union approved on 6 July 1439 taught that the souls of the truly penitent who die before they have made amends “are cleansed after death by cleansing pains,” and that the Masses, prayers and alms of the living “avail them in giving relief from such pains.” The union did not hold.

Luther came to purgatory by way of indulgences. In his Ninety-five Theses of 1517 he wrote, “They preach only human doctrines who say that as soon as the money clinks into the money chest, the soul flies out of purgatory,” and in those theses he still wrote of “souls in purgatory.” In the Smalcald Articles, which he drew up late in 1536 for a council the pope had called, he rejected purgatory outright, and he went back to Monica to do it: Augustine, the articles say, “leaves it in doubt whether there is one, and says that his mother asked to be remembered at the altar or Sacrament.”

Les chrétiens orthodoxes croient-ils au purgatoire ?

Orthodox Christians pray for their dead and do not believe in purgatory. The Orthodox Church in America says that “the Orthodox Church does not accept the teaching on purgatory that developed in more recent times in Roman Catholicism,” and the difference lies in what the prayer asks. Purgatory, it says, “implies that one should pray for the release of the souls of the departed from such punishment,” while the Orthodox pray “so that the Lord will have mercy on their souls, that He will grant them eternal rest ‘in the bosom of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob,’” because “those who have gone before us are still members of the Body of Christ, the Church.” Their prayer for the departed asks God to “give rest to the souls of Thy departed servants in a place of brightness, a place of refreshment, a place of repose, where all sickness, sighing, and sorrow have fled away.”

The Coptic Orthodox Metropolis of the Southern United States puts it in one sentence: “The Coptic Orthodox Church with all the Oriental Orthodox, the Eastern Orthodox and the Protestants churches reject the concept of purgatory.” Its reason is that purgatory “is against the doctrine of Atonement and Redemption.” The Copts pray for their departed all the same, “not because we believe in the purgatory but following St. Paul who prayed for Onesiphorus,” that “The Lord grant unto him that he may find mercy of the Lord in that day” (2 Timothy 1:18).

Les protestants croient-ils au purgatoire ?

No Protestant church in our comparison teaches it, and several of their confessions reject it by name. The Lutheran Smalcald Articles say that “purgatory, and every solemnity, rite, and commerce connected with it, is to be regarded as nothing but a specter of the devil,” because “only Christ, and not the works of men, are to help [set free] souls.” The Church of England’s Article XXII, agreed in 1562, calls “the Romish Doctrine concerning Purgatory” “a fond thing vainly invented, and grounded upon no warranty of Scripture, but rather repugnant to the Word of God.” That has not kept Anglicans from praying for their dead, and the Episcopal Church’s Book of Common Prayer, approved in 1979, prays in its burial service, “May his soul, and the souls of all the departed, through the mercy of God, rest in peace.”

The United Methodist Church keeps nearly the same words in Article XIV of its Articles of Religion, which calls “the Romish doctrine concerning purgatory” “a fond thing, vainly invented, and grounded upon no warrant of Scripture,” though the church now reads its old articles in the light of a later resolution, “With a View to Unity.” Presbyterian and Reformed churches hold the Westminster Confession of Faith, which teaches that at death the souls of the righteous go to “the highest heavens” and the souls of the wicked to hell, and adds, “Besides these two places, for souls separated from their bodies, the Scripture acknowledgeth none.”

The Salvation Army and the Churches of Christ answer the question by name as well. The Salvation Army’s Handbook of Doctrine describes purgatory as “a place for the soul to be purified and for a second chance to repent and embrace the gospel,” and says, “There is no substantial biblical foundation for such beliefs, which do not form part of Salvation Army doctrine.” For the Churches of Christ, Batsell Barrett Baxter’s tract asks, “Does the church of Christ believe in purgatory? No,” because the Bible’s silence “prevents the acceptance of the doctrine of purgatory.”

Most other Protestant confessions never take up purgatory at all. When they speak of death, they speak of one of two hopes, and the first is that a believer goes straight to Christ. The older Second London Baptist Confession of 1689, which some Baptist churches still keep, says the righteous are “received into paradise, where they are with Christ,” and, in the same words as Westminster, it allows no third place for the soul. The Southern Baptist Convention has its own statement, the Baptist Faith and Message of 2000, which never uses the word purgatory and says that the righteous “will dwell forever in Heaven with the Lord.” The Mennonite Confession of Faith of 1963, which Keystone Mennonite Fellowship still prints, teaches “that at death the righteous enter at once into conscious joy and fellowship with Christ.”

The second hope looks to the judgment, when every soul gives account to God. The Church of the Nazarene’s Articles of Faith say, “We believe in future judgment in which every person shall appear before God to be judged according to his or her deeds in this life.” The United Pentecostal Church International, a Oneness Pentecostal church, teaches that “the righteous will inherit eternal life, and the unrighteous eternal death.” The Amish hold the Dordrecht Confession of 1632, which says that “everyone shall receive in his own body according to that he hath done, whether it be good or evil.” Evangelical Friends of the Mid-America Yearly Meeting, who are Quakers, keep the Richmond Declaration of 1887, which says that “the punishment of the wicked and the blessedness of the righteous shall be everlasting.” The Assemblies of God has no paper on purgatory, but its paper on the final judgment leaves no second chance: “The Bible offers no possibility of repentance after death nor a lessening of the torment of separation from God (Luke 16:23–26).”

Three churches have nothing on purgatory and speak of death in other ways. A 1997 study paper of the Disciples of Christ’s Commission on Theology says that “in Jesus Christ, God’s judgment is accomplished, and it is revealed that sin will not have the last word.” For nondenominational and evangelical churches, the Lausanne Movement’s Cape Town Commitment of 2010 says of those who trust in Christ, “Being justified by faith we have peace with God and no longer face condemnation.” The United Church of Christ remembers its dead at Totenfest, a practice from its Evangelical tradition, when the church gathers to “remember and celebrate the lives of faithful people who have died.”

What do Adventists, Jehovah’s Witnesses and Latter-day Saints teach instead?

Seventh-day Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses have no place for purgatory, because they teach that nobody is conscious between death and the resurrection. The Adventists’ Fundamental Belief 26 says, “God, who alone is immortal, will grant eternal life to His redeemed. Until that day death is an unconscious state for all people.” Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that “a person who has died cannot feel anything and therefore cannot be cleansed by any fire of purgatory,” and both churches read the Preacher’s words, “the dead know not any thing” (Ecclesiastes 9:5).

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints teaches that “the postmortal spirit world is a place where the spirits of those who have died dwell before the Resurrection,” made up of “paradise, where the righteous dwell, and spirit prison, where those who did not know the gospel or who were wicked in mortality dwell.” The name comes from Peter’s letter, where Christ “went and preached unto the spirits in prison” (1 Peter 3:19), and the Church teaches that “if they accept the gospel and the ordinances performed for them in temples, they may leave spirit prison and dwell in paradise.” That hope is why Latter-day Saints do temple work for their ancestors, the practice described in Baptême pour les morts. It is not purgatory, since purgatory holds only the saved and spirit prison holds many who have not yet received the gospel, but it is one more answer to Monica’s question.

Whatever we were taught, we stand at the same graves, and John heard a word from heaven for all of us who do: “Blessed are the dead which die in the Lord from henceforth: Yea, saith the Spirit, that they may rest from their labours; and their works do follow them” (Revelation 14:13).


Plus de cette sérieComparaison des dénominationsVoir les 135 articles



Réponses

Laisser un commentaire

Share to...