Catholicism Demystified45 articles

Roman Catholic vs Catholic: The Same Church, With Exceptions



  • In everyday speech “Roman Catholic” and “Catholic” mean the same Church, the one led by the pope, and its own documents, such as Lumen Gentium 8 (1964), usually call it the Catholic Church.
  • “Catholic” comes from the Greek katholikos, universal, and the first Christian known to have called the Church catholic is Ignatius of Antioch, writing around 107 to 110.
  • English Protestant writers first used the double name “Roman Catholic” in the 1580s, and it probably became the official English style during the Spanish Match negotiations of 1618 to 1624.
  • The Church uses “Roman” too: the First Vatican Council (1870) spoke of “the holy, catholic, apostolic and Roman church,” and its dialogue with Anglicans runs through the Anglican–Roman Catholic International Commission.
  • The Catholic Church is a communion of 24 churches, the Latin Church and 23 Eastern Catholic churches, and the Eastern ones, 14 of them Byzantine, are Catholic without being of the Roman rite.
  • The Orthodox, Anglicans, Old Catholics and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America also call their churches catholic, even though Luther’s Small Catechism of 1529 says “one holy Christian Church.”
Catholicism DemystifiedSee all 45 articles in this series

In everyday speech the two names mean the same church: the one led by the pope, which its own documents usually call the Catholic Church. The 23 Eastern Catholic churches belong to that same Church under the pope, though they follow Eastern rites rather than the Roman (Latin) one. The Old Catholic churches also use the name Catholic, but they are outside communion with the pope.

“Roman Catholic” took hold in English after the Reformation and became the legal name in England. Most of the confusion that is left comes from a third word, catholic with a small c. It means universal or whole, and Christians who are not Roman Catholic, among them the Orthodox and Anglicans, still profess belief in a catholic Church when they say the creed.

Long before anyone quarrelled over the word, a bishop under guard on the road to his death in Rome gave it to the Church. He is the first Christian we know to do so, and he joined it to the presence of Jesus Christ.

Our free tool, Compare Christian Denominations, sets any two of 23 churches side by side on 55 questions.

The names side by side

Name Who uses it What it means
Catholic Church The Church’s own documents and most of its members The churches in communion with the pope, Latin and Eastern
Roman Catholic English speech and law since the 1600s; ecumenical bodies Usually the same Church; sometimes only its Latin members
Catholic, Apostolic and Roman Latin and the Romance languages; the First Vatican Council The same Church, named by the Creed and its tie to Rome
catholic, small c The creeds, said by Catholics, Orthodox and Anglicans Universal, whole: a mark of the true Church
Eastern Catholic 23 Eastern churches in communion with the pope Catholic, but not of the Roman rite
Old Catholic Churches of the Union of Utrecht, formed in 1889 Catholic in tradition, not in communion with the pope

What does “catholic” mean?

The word comes from the Greek katholikos, built on katholou, “throughout the whole”, and so it means universal. The Catechism of the Catholic Church gives it the same meaning: “The word ‘catholic’ means ‘universal,’ in the sense of ‘according to the totality’ or ‘in keeping with the whole’” (830).

The first Christian known to have used it of the Church is Ignatius of Antioch. He was a bishop, taken under guard from Syria to be killed in Rome, and on the way, around the year 107 to 110, he wrote to the Christians of Smyrna. In the 1885 translation of the Ante-Nicene Fathers he says:

“Wherever the bishop shall appear, there let the multitude [of the people] also be; even as, wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.”

Pope Benedict XVI called Ignatius “the first person in Christian literature to attribute to the Church the adjective ‘catholic’ or ‘universal’.” Scholars differ on exactly what the word meant to him, and translators render it differently: in J. B. Lightfoot’s version of 1891 it reads “there is the universal Church.”

In time the word became a name. Herbert Thurston, writing in the Catholic Encyclopedia in 1908, judged that this use “seems to have been clearly established by the beginning of the third century,” around the year 200, and that the word then implied “sound doctrine as opposed to heresy, and unity of organization as opposed to schism.” When Cyril of Jerusalem explained the Creed, around 347, he taught that the Church “is called Catholic then because it extends over all the world, from one end of the earth to the other; and because it teaches universally and completely one and all the doctrines which ought to come to men’s knowledge.” He had practical advice for travellers too. Other groups called their own meeting places the Lord’s House, so in a strange city they should “inquire not simply where the Lord’s House is,” he said, “but where is the Catholic Church.”

From there the word passed into the creeds we still say. The Apostles’ Creed, in the English the Vatican publishes, professes belief in “the holy Catholic Church, the communion of saints,” and the Nicene Creed in “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church.” Why Christians say a creed at all is one of the lessons in Christianity: What Christians Have Believed for 2,000 Years, a free course of eighteen short lessons.

The Catechism reads the word in two senses. The Church is catholic because Christ is present in her, and the Catechism quotes Ignatius to say so. And she is catholic because she “has been sent out by Christ on a mission to the whole of the human race” (831).

Where did the name “Roman Catholic” come from?

The name came out of the religious arguments of Elizabethan England. Herbert Thurston wrote about it in the Catholic Encyclopedia in 1912, and the earliest uses he could find were by Protestant writers of the 1580s. One of them was Robert Crowley, whose A Deliberat Answere of 1588 writes of “the Romane Catholiques.” As Thurston read it, the qualifier “was introduced by Protestant divines who highly resented the Roman claim to any monopoly of the term Catholic.” For their part, he wrote, “the evidence seems to show” that the Catholics of Elizabeth I’s and James I’s reigns would accept no name but Catholic. In his 1908 article, though, he says Catholics did not always seem to object to the double name and “sometimes used it themselves.”

Most likely it was diplomacy that made the name official, in the negotiations of 1618 to 1624 for the Spanish Match, a proposed English royal marriage to a Spanish princess. The Oxford English Dictionary, as Thurston quotes it, says the term was used in those talks “for conciliatory reasons,” and that after them it “was generally adopted as a non-controversial term.” Thurston judged the dictionary “is probably right” to date the official style to those talks. Until then, Acts of Parliament had called Catholics “Papists or Recusants.” Catholics began to use the new name themselves when they dealt with the Crown, and in 1661 the Irish clergy wrote to the king as “the Roman Catholick clergy of Ireland.”

Even in the 1890s people were still arguing over the name. For Queen Victoria’s Diamond Jubilee in 1897, and again when Edward VII came to the throne in 1901, the British government would accept an address from the Catholic bishops only in the style “the Roman Catholic Archbishop and Bishops in England.” In 1897 the bishops sent no address. In 1901 Cardinal Vaughan accepted the style, and then he explained it in a public speech: “the term Roman Catholic has two meanings; a meaning that we repudiate and a meaning that we accept.” What he rejected was the picture of one Catholic family with Roman, Anglo-Catholic and Greek branches. What he accepted was the word Roman in another sense: “with us the prefix Roman is not restrictive to a species, or a section, but simply declaratory of Catholic.”

What does the Church call itself?

In its teaching documents the Church usually calls itself the Catholic Church. The Second Vatican Council taught in 1964 that the one Church of Christ “subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the Bishops in communion with him” (Lumen Gentium 8). Pope Paul VI signed that constitution as bishop of the Catholic Church, Catholicae Ecclesiae Episcopus, and the Code of Canon Law of 1983 speaks of “the communion of the Catholic Church” (canon 205).

Yet the word Roman appears in its own texts as well. The First Vatican Council in 1870 opened its teaching on God with the words “The holy, catholic, apostolic and Roman church believes and acknowledges that there is one true and living God.” Pope Pius XII wrote in 1950 that “the Mystical Body of Christ and the Roman Catholic Church are one and the same thing” (Humani Generis 27).

The Holy See also uses the English name in its work with other churches. Its dialogue with the Anglican Communion runs through the Anglican–Roman Catholic International Commission. And in the declaration of 1965, when Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras I committed the excommunications of 1054 to oblivion, they spoke of “the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church of Constantinople.”

What does “Catholic, Apostolic and Roman” mean?

This is the Church’s name built from the Creed. Catholic and apostolic are two of the four marks the Nicene Creed gives the Church, and Roman names its bond with the Church of Rome and its bishop. The Catechism puts that bond in one sentence: local churches “are fully catholic through their communion with one of them, the Church of Rome” (834).

In Latin and the Romance languages it is common to say Catholic and Roman in that order, without apostolic, as in Ecclesia Catholica Romana and the French l’Église catholique romaine. The full form survives in Argentina’s constitution of 1853. In the text reformed in 1994 it still says that the federal government “sostiene el culto católico apostólico romano,” that it supports Catholic, Apostolic and Roman worship. English Catholics sometimes used this order too and spoke of the “Catholic Roman faith.” Thurston wrote that “it was felt that this inverted form contained no hint” of the Protestant claim that theirs was only the Roman branch of a wider Catholic family. Not everyone saw it that way. The Anglican Bishop Andrewes, in Tortura Torti of 1609, ridiculed Ecclesia Catholica Romana as a contradiction in terms. As Thurston translates him, the word Roman could only serve “to distinguish your Catholic Church from another Catholic Church which is not Roman.” Cardinal Vaughan gave the sense Catholics accept, that the word Roman “insists that the central point of Catholicity is Roman, the Roman See of St. Peter.”

Are all Catholics Roman Catholic?

Strictly speaking they are not, because the Catholic Church is a communion of 24 churches with their own law, called sui iuris. One is the Latin Church, to which the great majority of Catholics belong, and the other 23 are Eastern Catholic churches. In February 2026 Vatican News described all 24 as churches “that are in full communion with the Pope but maintain their own specific traditions, liturgies, laws, and governance.”

The Eastern churches come from five traditions: Alexandrian, Antiochene, Armenian, Chaldean and Byzantine. Each has its own name, such as the Maronite Church of Lebanon, the Syro-Malabar Church of India or the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. The Code of Canon Law of 1983 says of itself, “The canons of this Code regard only the Latin Church” (canon 1), and the Eastern churches have their own Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, promulgated in 1990. In the Second Vatican Council’s words, a rite is a church’s “liturgy, ecclesiastical discipline, and spiritual heritage,” and the Council called the churches of East and West “of equal dignity, so that none of them is superior to the others as regards rite” (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 3).

Fourteen of the 23 worship in the Byzantine rite, among them the largest of all the Eastern Catholic churches, the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church. Their liturgy, married priests and calendar are set out in Byzantine Catholic vs Roman Catholic. So whether “Roman Catholic” fits an Eastern Catholic depends on what you mean by it. If you mean, as Vaughan did, communion with the see of Rome, it does. If you mean it in the everyday sense, the Roman rite and the Latin Church, it does not.

Who else calls their church catholic?

Several churches outside the Catholic Church use the word in its older sense of universal or whole, and each explains it in its own way. The Orthodox Church says the Nicene Creed with its belief “in one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.” Thomas Hopko, in The Orthodox Faith, a handbook published by the Orthodox Church in America, explains that the word, as first used of the Church, “was a definition of quality rather than quantity.” A church is catholic when nothing essential is missing from it, “as is each and every Orthodox church today.” So in their own understanding Orthodox Christians are catholic without being Roman Catholic.

The Church of England describes itself as keeping “the catholic creeds” and as “catholic and reformed.” Within it, the Catholic tradition renewed by the Oxford Movement from the 1830s stresses the Church of England’s continuity with the Church of the early and medieval periods.

Where the Latin creed has sanctam Ecclesiam catholicam, Luther’s Small Catechism of 1529 confesses “one holy Christian Church, the communion of saints.” Thurston noted that “in Germany, Luther had omitted the word Catholic from the Creed,” while English Reformers such as John Foxe kept the word and claimed their own church as the true Catholic Church. The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America does claim the word, in its statement on ecumenism, The Vision of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. There it calls the Lutheran Confessions “catholic writings” which “assert that the Gospel is essential to the church for being one, holy, catholic, and apostolic,” and it describes itself as “a confessional church that is evangelical, catholic, and ecumenical.”

The Old Catholic churches of the Union of Utrecht were formed in 1889 by churches in the Netherlands, Germany and Switzerland, and they say what the word means to them in their founding Declaration of Utrecht. Its first article adopts the rule of Vincent of Lérins, to hold what has been believed everywhere, always and by all: “hoc est etenim vere proprieque catholicum,” for that is truly and properly catholic. Its second rejects the decrees of the First Vatican Council of July 1870 “concerning the infallibility and the universal episcopate or ecclesiastical plenitude of power of the Roman Pope.” At the same time it acknowledges the bishop of Rome’s historic primacy as “primus inter pares,” first among equals. In Germany and Switzerland the movement “grew out of protest against the decisions of Vatican I,” the council of 1869 to 1870.

“Christian Catholic” can mean simply a Catholic described as a Christian, which every Catholic is. It is also close to the name of the Swiss Old Catholic church, which calls itself the Christ Catholic Church of Switzerland.

Many churches still hold on to the old word, each in its own way. The prisoner who first gave it to the Church wrote it on his way to Rome, and he tied it to Christ himself: “wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.”


More from this seriesCatholicism DemystifiedSee all 45 articles



Responses

Leave a Reply

Share to...